Short-Term Investments vs. Long-Term Investments - Experian (2024)

In this article:

  • Short-Term Investments vs. Long-Term Investments
  • What Is a Short-Term Investment?
  • What Is a Long-Term Investment?
  • Short-Term vs. Long-Term Investing: Which Should You Choose?

Typically, short-term investments involve less risk than long-term investments, which give your money more time to grow and to recover from dips in the market. Having clear financial goals can help you decide whether to choose short- or long-term investments, and which vehicles within those categories make the most sense for you.

Without a concrete idea for what to do with your money, you could choose investments that are too risky, leading you to lose money allocated for financial goals such as a down payment. Or, you could fall short of your goals if you play it too safe and miss out on growth for things like retirement savings.

Here are the primary differences between short- and long-term investments and how to match them to your personal and financial goals.

Short-Term Investments vs. Long-Term Investments

When you invest for the short term, you'll need access to your money sooner, which means it's best to choose less risky investments. Conversely, when investing for the long term, your money has more time to recover from losses and to take advantage of growth in the stock market. That makes it more practical to pursue options that carry some risk.

Below are some of the key features of short-term and long-term investments.

Short-Term Investments vs. Long-Term Investments
Short-Term InvestmentsLong-Term Investments
More liquidity, meaning you can access your money more quickly and easilyLess liquidity, meaning there may be obstacles to withdrawing your money
Less volatility, meaning the value of your investments is more likely to stay stable over timeMore volatility, meaning the value of your investments can change substantially according to economic conditions and other factors
Easier to manage on your own without the help of a financial professionalMore likely to require active management or oversight by a financial professional
May have more flexible withdrawal optionsMay limit your options for penalty-free withdrawal (for example, retirement accounts that require you to hit a certain age before you can withdraw funds without a penalty)

What Is a Short-Term Investment?

Making a short-term investment generally means you plan to access the money in three years or less. Ideally, the investment method you choose should shield your money from losing value in such a short time. That typically means there's a trade-off: Your money will be safer, but you won't see as much growth as a riskier investment vehicle might provide.

Examples of short-term investments include anything highly liquid—in other words, investments you can cash in easily. That can include traditional or high-yield savings accounts, U.S. Treasury bills (not to be confused with longer-maturity Treasury bonds), money market accounts and short-term certificates of deposit (CDs). Bonds can also come with maturity dates of one to three years.

Especially in a low interest rate environment, your potential returns on a short-term investment may only serve to minimize losses due to inflation. As of early 2022, for example, interest rates on three-year CDs rarely topped 1.10%. But that's still better than keeping your money stashed in cash at home or in a savings account that pays an average 0.06% interest, according to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), for example.

Invest Your Money Smarter

Browse Top Brokerages

What Is a Long-Term Investment?

A long-term investing plan can involve higher-risk choices because your money has more time to bounce back after incurring losses. In most cases, making a long-term investment means you don't plan to access the money for 10 years or more. Saving in a retirement account such as an IRA or 401(k) is a way of investing for the long term.

Some types of long-term investments include stocks, longer-maturity bonds and mutual funds—or a group of investments, including stocks and bonds, overseen by a fund manager. Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are another type of investment that includes groups of stocks or bonds, but that can be traded more often than mutual funds. Real estate investment trusts (REITs) are also long-term investment options that allow investors to put their money toward real estate projects likely to produce returns. You'll buy shares in a REIT just as a stock gives you a share in a company.

The average consumer can protect themselves against some of the ups and downs of long-term investing by regularly contributing to a retirement or brokerage account, no matter the current state of the market. That's a strategy called dollar cost averaging, and it means that you'll have the opportunity to buy more stocks when they're priced lower and less when they're more expensive. In practice, this simply means setting up regular contributions—perhaps monthly or every time you get a paycheck—and leaving your money alone instead of trying to time the market.

Short-Term vs. Long-Term Investing: Which Should You Choose?

It's wise to have both short- and long-term investments that are matched to your goals. Setting aside money in a money market account or a CD is a good idea if you plan to use the money for a honeymoon in a year or two. An emergency fund, which should be accessible immediately, is better off in a high-yield or traditional savings account you can easily withdraw from.

Simultaneously, you may allocate other types of funds for long-term plans. Perhaps you save in a retirement account like a 401(k), and separately in a brokerage account because you plan to buy a house in 10 to 15 years. Choosing both short- and long-term investments makes sense as you set goals and priorities, as long as you also maintain a solid foundation of emergency savings.

Short-Term Investments vs. Long-Term Investments - Experian (2024)

FAQs

What is better, short-term investment or long-term investment? ›

Short-term investments offer quick returns and liquidity, suitable for immediate needs. Long-term investments provide higher growth potential over time, ideal for building wealth and retirement planning.

Is investing best for short or long term goals? ›

Money that you will need access to in a very short period of time should not be in the stock market; whereas money that you won't need for a long time, such as retirement, should be invested in the stock market to take advantage of the potential for greater returns.

What is the difference between short-term and long term investment accounting? ›

The long-term investment account differs largely from the short-term investment account in that short-term investments will most likely be sold, whereas the long-term investments will not be sold for years and, in some cases, may never be sold.

What is riskier short-term or long term investing? ›

Reduced Risk: Long-term investments tend to be less risky compared to short-term ones since they have more time to overcome market fluctuations and potential downturns.

What is the difference between long and short investments? ›

The distinction between going long and going short is brief but important: Being long a stock means that you own it and will profit if the stock rises. Being short a stock means that you have a negative position in the stock and will profit if the stock falls.

What are the disadvantages of long-term investment? ›

So here are some cons of long term investment.
  • No liquidity: Your capital stuck for long term.
  • Less Returns: In long term, return is very less as risk taking capacity in long term is low and return in long term is very stable returns.
  • Time taken: Long Term is involved in long term investment.
Jun 9, 2020

What are the disadvantages of short term investing? ›

Short-term investments tend to be unsustainable and unreliable, bringing higher volatility and erratic, unpredictable returns. Short-term investments can be here today and gone tomorrow, and it's precisely that volatility that can lead to a lucrative upside for those who dare take the risk to pursue.

Why is investing better for long term? ›

The longer you're invested, the more of that return you're likely to earn. But that doesn't mean you should just dump all your money into the market now. It could go up or down a lot in the short term. Instead, it's more prudent to invest regularly, every week or every month, and keep adding money over time.

Which is more profitable long or short? ›

That depends on the asset in question and the terms of the transaction. Generally speaking, going short is riskier than going long as there is no limit to how much you could lose and, in most cases, these positions require borrowing from a broker and paying interest for the privilege.

Are short term capital gains taxed differently than long term? ›

Short-term capital gains taxes are paid at the same rate as you'd pay on your ordinary income, such as wages from a job. Long-term capital gains tax is a tax applied to assets held for more than a year. The long-term capital gains tax rates are 0 percent, 15 percent and 20 percent, depending on your income.

What is the main difference between short term and long term finance? ›

Answer and Explanation:

Short term financing involves a smaller amount, while long term financing involves a huge amount of money, which is mainly used as capital expenditure. Short term loans are paid over a short time, mostly paid under one year while long term loans are payable in more than one year.

What is long term vs short term in accounting? ›

Short term debt is any debt that is payable within one year. Short-term debt shows up in the current liability section of the balance sheet. Long-term debt is debt that are notes payable in a period of time greater than one year. Long-term debt shows up in the long-term liabilities section of the balance sheet.

What is the biggest threat to all long term investments? ›

Possibly the greatest of these risks is that a portfolio with too much cash won't earn enough over the long term to stay ahead of inflation and that it won't provide enough protection against inevitable downturns in stock markets.

Which is the safest short-term investment? ›

  • High-yield savings accounts. ...
  • Cash management accounts. ...
  • Money market accounts. ...
  • Short-term corporate bond funds. ...
  • Short-term U.S. government bond funds. ...
  • Money market mutual funds. ...
  • No-penalty certificates of deposit.

Which is better, long term or short-term investment? ›

There are several risks that are involved with investments which is why the stock market has a 50:50 success rate. It is for this reason, that short-term equity investments are considered as risky, whereas long-term investments are considered much more profitable and consistent in terms of returns.

Is it better to buy short term or long term options? ›

Time value and extrinsic value of short-term options decay rapidly due to their short durations. Time value does not decay as rapidly for long-term options because they have a longer duration. Time value decay is minimal for a relatively long period because the expiration date is a long time away.

Is it better to finance long term or short term? ›

Long-term loans tend to carry less risk for the borrower, but interest rates tend to be at least slightly higher than for short-term loans. Long-term financing is typically used to cover equipment purchases, vehicles, facilities, and other assets with a relatively long useful life.

Which is better long term or short term trading? ›

There are several risks that are involved with investments which is why the stock market has a 50:50 success rate. It is for this reason, that short-term equity investments are considered as risky, whereas long-term investments are considered much more profitable and consistent in terms of returns.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Fr. Dewey Fisher

Last Updated:

Views: 6417

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (42 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Fr. Dewey Fisher

Birthday: 1993-03-26

Address: 917 Hyun Views, Rogahnmouth, KY 91013-8827

Phone: +5938540192553

Job: Administration Developer

Hobby: Embroidery, Horseback riding, Juggling, Urban exploration, Skiing, Cycling, Handball

Introduction: My name is Fr. Dewey Fisher, I am a powerful, open, faithful, combative, spotless, faithful, fair person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.