Private Equity Valuations Methods
Private equity firms typically use several methods for valuing companies in their portfolios. These methods include:
1.Market approach
a)Comparable Company Analysis (CCA)
b)Precedent Transaction Analysis (PTA)
2.Discounted cash flow analysis
3.Multiple ratios
a)Price-to-earnings ratio (P/E ratio)
b)Enterprise value-to-EBITDA ratio (EV/EBITDA)
c)Price-to-sales ratio (P/S ratio)
4.Asset-based approach
Market Aproach of Valuation method:
Market approach is a commonly used valuation method in private equity. The market approach involves comparing the target company to similar companies in the same industry that have recently been sold or are publicly traded. This method assumes that the value of the target company is similar to the value of comparable companies, based on factors such as financial performance, growth potential, and market position.
The market approach typically involves two primary methods of valuation
A)Comparable company analysis:
Comparable Company Analysis (CCA) - This method involves identifying a set of publicly traded companies that are similar to the target company in terms of size, industry, and financial performance. Analysts then use various financial metrics such as price-to-earnings ratio, enterprise value-to-revenue ratio, and others to compare the target company's valuation to those of the comparable companies. This method provides a range of potential valuations for the target company based on the average valuation multiples of the comparable companies.
Example :
The private equity firm identifies a group of publicly traded software companies that are similar to the target company in terms of size, industry, and financial performance. They then collect financial data and valuation multiples for each of these companies, including:
Revenue
EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization)
Price-to-Earnings Ratio (P/E)
Enterprise Value-to-Revenue Ratio (EV/R)
Enterprise Value-to-EBITDA Ratio (EV/EBITDA)
After analyzing the data, the firm determines that the average P/E ratio for the comparable companies is 30x, and the average EV/EBITDA ratio is 15x. Based on the target company's financial performance, they estimate that the company's P/E ratio could be around 28x, and its EV/EBITDA ratio could be around 13x. Using these estimates and the average ratios from the comparable companies, the firm arrives at a potential valuation range of $500 million to $600 million for the target company.
B)Precedent Transaction Analysis (PTA)
The private equity firm identifies several recent transactions in the software industry that are similar to the target company in terms of size, industry, and financial performance. They then collect data on the transaction prices and financial metrics for each of these transactions, including:
·Purchase price
·Revenue multiple
·EBITDA multiple
After analyzing the data, the firm determines that the average revenue multiple for the comparable transactions is 10x, and the average EBITDA multiple is 12x. Based on the target company's financial performance, they estimate that the company's revenue multiple could be around 11x, and its EBITDA multiple could be around 13x. Using these estimates and the average multiples from the comparable transactions, the firm arrives at a potential valuation of $550 million for the target company.
2. Discount cash flow analysis:
Discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis is a common valuation method used in private equity funds to estimate the present value of a company's expected future cash flows. The DCF analysis takes into account the time value of money and the risks associated with the company's future cash flows.
Here's how DCF analysis is typically used in private equity:
Project future cash flows: The private equity firm forecasts the expected future cash flows of the company, taking into account factors such as revenue growth, expenses, and capital expenditures. These projections may be based on historical financial data, market trends, and the company's growth potential.
Calculate the discount rate: The private equity firm calculates the discount rate to be used in the DCF analysis. This rate reflects the time value of money and the risks associated with the company's future cash flows. The discount rate may be based on factors such as the company's cost of capital, market risk premium, and the company's perceived risk level.
Calculate the present value: The private equity firm discounts the projected future cash flows to their present value using the discount rate calculated in step 2. The resulting present values are then summed to arrive at an estimated total present value for the company.
Adjust for additional factors: The private equity firm may make additional adjustments to the estimated present value to reflect factors such as the company's debt levels, tax liabilities, and other liabilities or assets that may affect its valuation.
Compare to market and other valuations: The private equity firm compares the estimated present value of the company to other valuation methods such as the market approach and precedent transactions analysis. This helps the firm to determine whether the estimated value is reasonable and to identify potential areas of risk or opportunity.
Overall, DCF analysis can be a useful tool for private equity firms in determining the fair value of a company and assessing the risks and opportunities associated with its future cash flows. However, it's important to note that DCF analysis is highly dependent on the accuracy of the projections used and the discount rate assumptions made, and should be used in conjunction with other valuation methods and due diligence to arrive at a comprehensive view of the company's value.
Example :
Here's an example of how a private equity firm might use DCF analysis to value a company:
Suppose a private equity firm is considering acquiring a technology company, and it expects the company to generate $10 million in annual cash flows for the next 5 years, growing at a rate of 5% per year thereafter. The firm estimates a discount rate of 12%, based on the company's perceived risk level and the cost of capital for similar companies.
Using these assumptions, the DCF analysis would yield a present value for the company's cash flows of:
PV = (CF1 / (1+r)^1) + (CF2 / (1+r)^2) + ... + (CF5 / (1+r)^5) + (CF6 / (r-g)(1+r)^5)
where:
CF1 = $10 million (year 1 cash flow)
r = 12% (discount rate)
g = 5% (long-term growth rate)
CF6 = $201.2 million (terminal value)
Plugging in the values, we get:
PV = ($10 million / (1+0.12)^1) + ($10.5 million / (1+0.12)^2) + ... + ($12.76 million / (1+0.12)^5) + ($201.2 million / (0.07 x (1+0.12)^5))
= $180.9 million
This indicates that the private equity firm estimates the fair value of the technology company to be $180.9 million based on its expected cash flows and discount rate. The firm might compare this valuation to other methods such as the market approach or precedent transactions analysis to arrive at a more comprehensive view of the company's value.
3.Multiple Ratio Method:
The multiple ratio method is a valuation technique commonly used in private equity. It involves calculating the ratio of certain financial metrics for the target company and then comparing those ratios to similar ratios for other comparable companies in the same industry. The goal is to determine a valuation range for the target company based on the multiples of its peers.
A)Price-to-earnings Ratio(P/E):
Price-to-earnings ratio (P/E ratio) is a commonly used valuation metric in private equity. It measures the price of a company's stock relative to its earnings per share (EPS). A high P/E ratio suggests that investors expect the company to grow rapidly in the future, while a low P/E ratio indicates that investors are not optimistic about the company's future prospects.
Here's an example of how a private equity firm might use the P/E ratio method to value a company:
Suppose a private equity firm is considering acquiring a consumer goods company. The company has an EPS of $2 and a current stock price of $30 per share. The P/E ratio can be calculated as follows:
P/E ratio = Stock price / EPS
= $30 / $2
= 15x
The firm identifies a set of comparable companies in the same industry with an average P/E ratio of 20x. Based on its analysis of the target company and the industry, the firm estimates that the company should have a P/E ratio of 18x.
Using the P/E ratio, the firm can estimate the fair value of the target company:
Fair value = EPS x Estimated P/E ratio
= $2 x 18
= $36
This indicates that the private equity firm estimates the fair value of the consumer goods company to be $36 per share based on the P/E ratio method. The firm might compare this valuation to other methods such as the discounted cash flow analysis or the comparable company analysis to arrive at a more comprehensive view of the company's value
B)Enterprise Value-to-EBITDA (EV/EBITDA):
The enterprise value-to-EBITDA (EV/EBITDA) ratio is a commonly used valuation metric in private equity. It measures a company's enterprise value relative to its earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA). A low EV/EBITDA ratio indicates that a company may be undervalued, while a high ratio suggests that it may be overvalued.
Here's an example of how a private equity firm might use the EV/EBITDA method to value a company:
Suppose a private equity firm is considering acquiring a technology company. The company has an EBITDA of $20 million and a total debt of $50 million. The firm identifies a set of comparable companies in the same industry and calculates their average EV/EBITDA multiple, which is commonly used in the industry.
The comparable companies have an average EV/EBITDA multiple of 10x. Based on its analysis of the target company and the industry, the firm estimates that the company should have an EV/EBITDA multiple of 12x.
Using these multiples, the firm can estimate the fair value of the target company:
Enterprise value = EBITDA x EV/EBITDA multiple
= $20 million x 12
= $240 million
To calculate the equity value, the firm needs to subtract the net debt from the enterprise value:
Equity value = Enterprise value - Net debt
Recommended by LinkedIn
= $240 million - $50 million
= $190 million
This indicates that the private equity firm estimates the fair value of the technology company to be $190 million based on the EV/EBITDA method. The firm might compare this valuation to other methods such as the discounted cash flow analysis or the comparable company analysis to arrive at a more comprehensive view of the company's value.
C)Price-to-Sales (P/S) ratio :
The price-to-sales (P/S) ratio is a valuation method that compares a company's stock price to its revenue per share. It is often used in private equity to value companies that have low or negative earnings but still have significant revenue growth potential.
Here's an example of how a private equity firm might use the P/S ratio to value a company:
Suppose a private equity firm is considering acquiring a software company. The company has revenue of $100 million and 10 million shares outstanding, resulting in revenue per share of $10. The firm identifies a set of comparable companies in the same industry and calculates their average P/S ratio, which is commonly used in the industry.
The comparable companies have an average P/S ratio of 5x. Based on its analysis of the target company and the industry, the firm estimates that the company should have a P/S ratio of 6x.
Using these multiples, the firm can estimate the fair value of the target company:
Enterprise value = Revenue per share x P/S ratio
= $10 x 6
= $60
To calculate the equity value, the firm needs to subtract the net debt from the enterprise value:
Equity value = Enterprise value - Net debt
Suppose the company has no debt, then:
Equity value = Enterprise value
= $60
This indicates that the private equity firm estimates the fair value of the software company to be $60 million based on the P/S ratio method. The firm might compare this valuation to other methods such as the discounted cash flow analysis or the comparable company analysis to arrive at a more comprehensive view of the company's value.
4)Asset-Based approach:
The asset-based approach is a valuation method used in private equity that estimates the value of a company based on its assets and liabilities. It is particularly relevant for companies that have a significant amount of tangible assets, such as property, equipment, and inventory.
The asset-based approach involves two primary methods:
Here's an example of how a private equity firm might use the asset-based approach to value a company:
Suppose a private equity firm is considering investing in a manufacturing company. The company has the following assets and liabilities on its balance sheet:
Assets:
Property, plant, and equipment: $50 million
Inventory: $20 million
Accounts receivable: $10 million
Liabilities:
Accounts payable: $5 million
Long-term debt: $25 million
To apply the ANAV method, the firm might hire a third-party appraiser to determine the fair market value of the assets and liabilities. The appraiser values the property, plant, and equipment at $60 million, the inventory at $25 million, and the accounts receivable at $8 million. The appraiser values the accounts payable at $4 million and the long-term debt at $27 million.
Using these values, the ANAV of the company is calculated as follows:
ANAV = (Fair market value of assets) - (Fair market value of liabilities)
= ($60M + $25M + $8M) - ($4M + $27M)
= $62 million
Alternatively, if the firm decides to use the liquidation value method, it might assume that the assets would sell for 70% of their fair market value in a liquidation scenario. In this case, the liquidation value of the assets would be:
Liquidation value of assets = 70% x ($60M + $25M + $8M) = $63.7 million
This indicates that the private equity firm estimates the fair value of the manufacturing company to be around $62 million to $63.7 million based on the asset-based approach. The firm might compare this valuation to other methods such as the discounted cash flow analysis or the comparable company analysis to arrive at a more comprehensive view of the company's value.
