My mom taught me there's such thing as 'too frugal,' and it's a lesson I share with financial planning clients every day (2024)

Paid non-client promotion: Affiliate links for the products on this page are from partners that compensate us (see our advertiser disclosure with our list of partners for more details). However, our opinions are our own. See how we rate investing products to write unbiased product reviews.

  • Growing up, my mom taught me to balance frugality with spending where it makes you happy.
  • As an adult, I decide where to splurge and cut back based on her lessons.
  • I share the same ideas with my financial planning clients: You don't have to be frugal all the time.

Thanks for signing up!

Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go.

As a kid, I never fully understood why my mom would go shopping almost every other week, dragging us along to multiple stores.

As an adult now I completely understand. Shopping is one of the activities that truly makes her happy. My mom loves food, travel, entertainment, and shopping. These are areas where she will splurge.

However, to compensate for this, she is more frugal or cost-conscious in other areas. This balance allows her to do the things she loves while still saving and investing for the future. Her splurging has not derailed her retirement plans at all.

Growing up, she would often preach that life requires balance. As an adult now who has a career in financial planning, I wholeheartedly agree with her.

I've taken her lessons on balance into adulthood

Being frugal is not a bad thing. It only becomes an issue when it is taken to the extreme. I believe that everyone should have some sort of "frugality" as a part of their life, but you must be smart about it. It is okay to splurge on the activities that you love doing, but you may have to be willing to be cost-conscious or cut back on other activities.

This truly benefited me and my brother as kids growing up. We were able to have many vacations and entertainment experiences that we will cherish forever. Now as an adult, I am very adamant about prioritizing the activities that I love such as travel, entertainment, and fitness, while being a bit more cost conscious with other things. I do not have to feel bad about spending $5,000 on a vacation because I am willing to live in a more affordable home with a smaller monthly payment.

My mom would often tell us "You get what you pay for." She taught us that sometimes it is worth spending more money for quality products. If you are too frugal, you may find yourself spending more money in the long run than you expected because of poor quality.

I teach my clients balance, too

I have helped many clients over the years take that dream vacation or buy that dream home or car. Not one of them regret their decision.

Yes, it is very important to build savings for retirement or future expenses. But it is also healthy and important to enjoy your present life, as tomorrow is not promised. To help clients make these dreams happen, I have them create a list of goals and priorities. We dive deeper into what is important to them. I often ask them questions such as, "If you had one year to live, what would you do with your time?"

When I run retirement projections for clients, I often notice that many are saving much more than necessary for their spending goals in retirement, sacrificing happiness today when they don't have to. It's OK to be frugal for a short period of time if you are saving towards a larger goal such as a down payment for a home. However, extended periods of severe frugality can harm your well-being.

Extreme frugality can be mentally and socially draining, and it can cause isolation and distance from those you love. Spend that extra dollar sometimes to create new experiences with your family and friends. If you want to be frugal, make sure that it is for a goal or purpose and with limitations.

Frugality should not take away from the joy of living. Do what you love and save money on other things.

This article was originally published in November 2022.

Jovan Johnson

Jovan Johnson, MBA, CFP®, CPA/PFS is the founder ofPiece of Wealth Planning LLC, a virtual fee-only financial planning firm based in Atlanta, Georgia, and serving clients nationwide.His firm is dedicated to serving charitably inclined individuals and families who want to make a meaningful impact. Jovan partners with individuals and families to help them accomplish their life goals, live well, give generously, serve others, and leave a legacy. He is very passionate about personal finance and providing clarity to others around the true meaning of wealth. Follow Jovan on Instagram@pieceofwealthplanning.

My mom taught me there's such thing as 'too frugal,' and it's a lesson I share with financial planning clients every day (2024)

FAQs

Is being frugal a bad thing? ›

Being frugal is not a bad thing. It only becomes an issue when it is taken to the extreme. I believe that everyone should have some sort of "frugality" as a part of their life, but you must be smart about it.

Why do people avoid financial planning? ›

People dislike financial planning as they feel they do not understand concepts and are unable to visualize different scenarios and variables. But being prepared with a financial plan will support us to achieve our goals, Build your wealth, and provide financial comfort during emergencies.

What are the 5 importance of personal financial planning? ›

Financial planning isn't just about investing; it's about what money can do for your confidence, security, and quality of life—such as the protection that life insurance offers or the peace of mind that an emergency fund can provide. Research also shows that planning supports sound money habits as well.

At what age should you first start financial planning? ›

When You Start Making Your Own Money. The first time you should start financial planning is once you start earning, regardless of age or income. Of course, there is nothing wrong with celebrating your first paycheck! But years down the road, you will be happy that you started on the right foot by planning ahead.

Is extreme cheapskate a mental illness? ›

The American Psychiatric Association defines frugality as a symptom of obsessive-compulsive personality disorder (OCPD) when someone “adopts a miserly spending style toward both self and others.” Extreme frugality is an amplified version of that, and it often involves viewing spending as a bad thing no matter how much ...

What is toxic frugality? ›

Frugality is the practice of being wise with money and avoiding wastefulness. It's a virtue that many people admire. It fosters responsible financial habits and can lead to a more sustainable life. But there's a darker side to frugality that can be detrimental to our quality of life. This is known as “toxic frugality.”

What is the biggest flaw of financial planning? ›

Lacking a plan is the most significant mistake you can make. Without one, you're essentially navigating without direction, relying on luck. A financial plan allows you to monitor your earnings and spending, establish objectives, and make well-informed financial choices.

What are the disadvantages of a financial planner? ›

The benefits of becoming an advisor include unlimited earning potential, a flexible work schedule, and the ability to tailor one's practice. The drawbacks include high stress, the hard work needed to build a client base, and the ongoing need to meet regulatory requirements.

Why do most people get into financial trouble? ›

The reasons that most people struggle financially will vary on the individual case but can include a lack of financial literacy, a scarcity mindset, self-esteem issues leading to overspending, and unavoidable high costs of living.

Which action can derail your financial plan? ›

Final answer:

Misuse of credit can derail a financial plan by accumulating debt and negatively impacting credit scores.

Do I need a financial plan? ›

A financial plan can give you confidence and a positive outlook because it eliminates uncertainty and confusion around finances. It also offers you the assurance that you're on the right path for reaching your goals.

What happens if you have no retirement savings? ›

You may have to rely on Social Security

Many retirees with little to no savings rely solely on Social Security as their main source of income. You can claim Social Security benefits as early as age 62, but your benefit amount will depend on when you start filing for the benefit.

Is $20,000 a good amount of savings? ›

Having $20,000 in a savings account is a good starting point if you want to create a sizable emergency fund. When the occasional rainy day comes along, you'll be financially prepared for it. Of course, $20,000 may only go so far if you find yourself in an extreme situation.

Can I retire at 45 with $1 million dollars? ›

Achieving retirement before 50 may seem unreachable, but it's entirely doable if you can save $1 million over your career. The keys to making this happen within a little more than two decades are a rigorous budget and a comprehensive retirement plan.

Is frugality a mental illness? ›

Fear of spending money or excessive frugality is sometimes known as Chrometophobia, a Specific Phobia related to money. Fears about spending money may also be involved in obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD).

Is frugal a red flag? ›

RED FLAG #3: Overly frugal

This can be a tough red flag to spot since recession worries have most of us saving more for a rainy day, but excessive frugality can negatively affect personal relationships and quality of life.

Is frugal positive or negative? ›

Frugal is a much more positive word than 'stingy'. The word can also be used with food and clothes. When you say that you had a 'frugal lunch', it means you had a simple lunch.

Is frugality negative? ›

While being frugal has gotten a bad rap, frugality is not a dirty word. On the contrary, it's a valuable skill for building wealth. Frugality is the attitude and mindset of saving more and spending less.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carmelo Roob

Last Updated:

Views: 5656

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (45 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carmelo Roob

Birthday: 1995-01-09

Address: Apt. 915 481 Sipes Cliff, New Gonzalobury, CO 80176

Phone: +6773780339780

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Gaming, Jogging, Rugby, Video gaming, Handball, Ice skating, Web surfing

Introduction: My name is Carmelo Roob, I am a modern, handsome, delightful, comfortable, attractive, vast, good person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.