Given the Risks of a Cashless Society, Why Not Just Keep Cash? (2024)

Privacy is the third challenge raised. Cash can be exchanged anonymously, leaving no digital trail. This offers people a choice for any given transaction, enabling them to ask: is this purchase safe and unproblematic to appear on statements and form part of my digital trail? If not, they can use cash. Additionally, with transaction tracking, there is the possibility of financial data being misused, either for fraudulent or other criminal use, or by unscrupulous organisations. In a cashless world, a government could track an individual via their spending, and even cut them off, leaving them unable to pay for goods and services. Even today, cashless spending opens the possibility of analysis by third parties not involved in a transaction. For example, an insurance company could adjust an individual’s premiums based on how much junk food and alcohol they have purchased in the past year.

The fourth challenge is inclusivity, with Hensley pointing out: ‘some economists argue that a cashless society would lead to increased inequality, as the wealthy would be able to benefit from the convenience of digital payments while the poor would be left behind.’ Clearly, this is already an issue, but with cash accessible and usable by all, everyone has the opportunity to participate in the economy. By removing cash, the risk of excluding people becomes unavoidable.

In conclusion, Hensley also mentions cashless payments require infrastructure that may not be available in all parts of all countries, they pose technological challenges—with a need to develop more secure payment methods and ensure systems are fully scalable—and also present social and cultural challenges, with many people currently relying on the tangibility of cash to help them budget.

He suggests that ‘despite these challenges, the move towards a cashless society is likely to continue.’ However, there is a critical difference between a future in which cash and cashless options continue to operate side by side, and one in which cash is neither widely accessible nor widely accepted. The former would allow people choice in how they pay and ensure vital low level economic functions could continue in emergencies such as nationwide cyberattacks or natural disasters impacting infrastructure. The latter would depend on 24/7 connectivity and solutions provided by for-profit organisations with agendas, exposing societies to all the risks discussed above.

These points make a strong case for the preservation of payment choice, with the best possible future economy being one which supports both cash and cashless options, harnessing the benefits of each and allowing people the freedom to select how they want to pay on a transaction by transaction basis.

Given the Risks of a Cashless Society, Why Not Just Keep Cash? (2024)

FAQs

Given the Risks of a Cashless Society, Why Not Just Keep Cash? ›

In an economy with cash and cashless working together, when the latter is unavailable, people can continue to make essential purchases using cash. A cashless society would rely on a complex network of digital systems, which would be vulnerable to cyberattacks.

What are the risks of a cashless society? ›

Identity theft and compromised personal information are potential dangers in a cashless economy, but privacy might be compromised in other ways too. When you pay digitally, you always leave a digital footprint, and this footprint is easily monitored by financial institutions.

What happens to your cash in a cashless society? ›

A cashless society is a concept in which money changes hands through digital means rather than physical banknotes or coins.

How does a cashless society affect the poor? ›

Crucially, this substitution has significant consequences for social inequality: while people with higher incomes typically benefit from cashless payments through easy and frictionless payments and access to short-term credit, people with lower incomes become increasingly dependent on financial services for which they ...

Why cashless is better than cash? ›

However, cashless payments offer greater security because transactions are recorded and can be easily traced. There is also no need to carry huge amounts of cash to deposit into a bank account, which also reduces the risks of loss and theft.

Should we get rid of cash? ›

For instance, using cash instead of credit or debit cards may help keep some people from overspending, because you can see how little is left in your wallet after every purchase. In short, getting rid of cash would impose hardships on society's most vulnerable people and could jeopardize our privacy.

Why cash will never go away? ›

With so much business still conducted in cash, don't expect it to disappear any time soon. Besides, some customers cannot pay with anything but cash, since they are unbanked or under-banked.

Why do banks want to get rid of cash? ›

Why Eliminate Cash? Cash can be used in criminal activities such as money laundering and tax evasion because it is difficult to trace. Digital transactions or electronic money create an audit trail for law enforcement and financial institutions and can aid governments in economic policymaking.

Is USA going cashless? ›

Summary: Americans are using cash less frequently and making payments more often by credit card or through payment apps. Yet, many CFI customers still like having cash as an option.

Which banks are going cashless? ›

Commonwealth Bank, ANZ, NAB and Westpac all confirmed on Friday that there are no current plans to go cashless. This comes after Macquarie Bank announced it would phase out cash and cheque services across all its banking and wealth management products from January to November 2024.

How long until cashless society? ›

Physical currency isn't becoming obsolete any time soon, so it's important to weigh up your options before deciding to go fully cashless in 2024. Ensuring you can accept some cashless payments though, is essential to keeping with today's trends and customer expectations.

Should we live in a cashless society? ›

The Drawbacks of a Cashless Society

Without cash, we would be forced to leave a record of everything we buy. While this may not bother some, there are many who worry that governments and/or corporations could use our purchasing histories as a way to track us, monitor us, and even intimidate us.

Are we really headed for a cashless society? ›

Nope. We might use less cash, but our society still has a long way to go before it's totally and completely cashless. And just because some stores didn't want to accept dollar bills for a while (and maybe still don't), that doesn't mean a cashless society is here to stay.

What country has gone almost completely cashless? ›

Norways is the most cashless country, with only around 2% of payments being made by cash, and 100% of the population having a bank account.

Is China cashless? ›

As of June 2023, about 943 million people in mainland China used mobile payments, bolstering the country's status as the world's largest cashless society.

Why are so many places going cashless? ›

No Cash Processing Costs

Businesses that have lots of cash often have to pay for armored car services. Small businesses spend billions of dollars per year on cash processing costs, but those that choose to go cashless avoid these expenses.

How close are we to a cashless society? ›

11% of US adults have completely stopped using cash, up from 5% five years ago (Source: Gallup) The average number of cash payments fell from 26% in 2019 to 20% in 2021 (Source: Federal Reserve) Between 2012 and 2022, cheque transactions declined by almost half (Source: Federal Reserve)

What impact would a cashless society have on various demographics? ›

It is difficult to say at present what consequences this might have, but it will likely further limit financial access for groups in society that currently lack any means of payment other than cash. Competition and redundancy in the payments infrastructure will likely be reduced if the state is no longer a participant.

What are the challenges of cashless economy? ›

The main disadvantage of a cashless society consists of privacy issues and hacking of accounts. Prevailing poverty; backwardness and illiteracy; a large unorganized sector cannot switch to cashless economy so easily.

What are the benefits and consequences of a cashless society? ›

The Benefits of a Cashless Society
  • Convenience. Swiping a credit card or scanning your phone makes buying things quick and simple. ...
  • Crime Prevention. If you're not carrying hundreds of dollars in cash, you're less of a target for robbery. ...
  • Stability. ...
  • Less Privacy. ...
  • Decreased Monetary Security. ...
  • More Sophisticated Criminality.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duane Harber

Last Updated:

Views: 6484

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duane Harber

Birthday: 1999-10-17

Address: Apt. 404 9899 Magnolia Roads, Port Royceville, ID 78186

Phone: +186911129794335

Job: Human Hospitality Planner

Hobby: Listening to music, Orienteering, Knapping, Dance, Mountain biking, Fishing, Pottery

Introduction: My name is Duane Harber, I am a modern, clever, handsome, fair, agreeable, inexpensive, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.