7 in 10 PIP appeals won on the same evidence DWP already held (2024)

The claim by the DWP that they lose 70% of PIP appeals mainly because the claimant produces new evidence at their hearing has been proved to be untrue, the Benefits and Work has highlighted.

According to the DWP’s own statistics, 59% of appeals are won by the claimant because the tribunal reached a different conclusion based on the same facts, with new written evidence making a difference in just 1% of cases.

The statistics were revealed in answer toa recent parliamentary question.

They show that in 2021 the reasons that claimants won their PIP appeal were:

  • New written evidence provided at the hearing: 1%
  • Cogent oral evidence: 32%
  • Reached a different conclusion on substantially the same facts: 59%
  • Other: 7%

Cogent oral evidence does not suggest new evidence, says Benefits and Work.

Instead it suggests that the tribunal asked detailed questions and the claimant was able to answer them in a way that was detailed, consistent and credible.

So, in 91% of cases the claimant won without any new evidence being provided.

And in just a tiny 1% of cases was it new written evidence, for example a medical report, that swung the outcome.

Benefits and Work concludes:

“What this suggests is that making sure you give the most detailed evidence possible in your claim form, which the appeal panel will have a copy of, and giving oral evidence that is consistent with what you have written will be very persuasive for tribunals. This will apply not just to PIP, but to other benefits related to health conditions, such as DLA, ESA and UC for people unable to work.

“If you have prepared well for the hearing, in terms of knowing what is going to happen, what kinds of questions you are likely to be asked and the importance of being clear, accurate and to the point in your answers then you have an exceedingly good chance of getting the correct award.

“Given the difficulty most claimants have in getting new medical evidence, this should be very reassuring information.”

Source and for further information seeDWP lie exposed - new evidence is not why they lose 7 in 10 PIP appealsavailable from benefitsandwork.co.uk.

7 in 10 PIP appeals won on the same evidence DWP already held (2024)

FAQs

7 in 10 PIP appeals won on the same evidence DWP already held? ›

7 in 10 PIP appeals won on the same evidence DWP already held. The claim by the DWP that they lose 70% of PIP appeals mainly because the claimant produces new evidence at their hearing has been proved to be untrue, the Benefits and Work has highlighted.

What is the success rate of PIP appeals? ›

The success rates for benefits appeals overall was 62%, but this varies according to the benefit involved: PIP 69%, up 1% DLA 61%, down 5%

Can you appeal PIP twice? ›

You can certainly make a new claim while waiting for your Tribunal but be aware that the new claim will create a new Decision as well which will supersede any Decision made at your appeal.

How likely am I to win PIP appeal? ›

It can take a long time to get to a tribunal hearing - how long it takes will vary depending on where you live. The process can be draining but it's worth remembering that more than half of people who appeal their PIP decision win at a tribunal. If you feel the decision is wrong, don't be put off appealing.

What happens if I lose my PIP appeal? ›

If you lose your appeal

You can reapply for PIP and start the process again, but unless something has changed you're unlikely to get a different decision.

Has anyone had a successful PIP mandatory reconsideration? ›

The Government's figure for the mandatory reconsideration success rate is under 20%. That is for any additional points being scored, never mind getting to the points that persons should have scored.

Do most PIP claims get rejected? ›

The overall average success rate for PIP claims is 52%, but this varies widely depending on your main disabling condition. For example, PIP claims for Rheumatoid Arthritis have a success rate of 74.7%, whilst those for Type 1 Diabetes are as low as 28%.

How many PIP decisions are overturned? ›

9% of initial decisions following a PIP assessment have been appealed and 4% have been overturned at a tribunal hearing.

How many times can I apply for PIP? ›

There is no restriction on you making a new claim for PIP.

How long does it take for PIP to reconsider? ›

Some reconsiderations take two weeks, some take several months. If you have not received your Mandatory Reconsideration Notice, it is a good idea to call the DWP after: 2 weeks to check they have logged your Mandatory Reconsideration. 8 weeks to check how much longer it will take.

How do I make a successful PIP appeal? ›

You need to give specific reasons why you disagree with the decision. Use your decision letter, statement of reasons and medical assessment report to make a note of each of the statements you disagree with and why. Give facts, examples and medical evidence (if available) to support what you're saying.

How long are PIP claims taking 2023? ›

The DWP has taken steps to halve wait times for new PIP applications from six to three months, but hundreds of thousands are still being left to wait far too long for a review of their payments.

What is the latest PIP news for 2023? ›

From December 2023 the Annual DLA to PIP Reassessment statistics will be extended to include second and subsequent attempts to claim PIP following a DLA claim, rather than just the first attempt as in the latest update (December 2022).

Can PIP be reinstated? ›

If you think the DWP made a mistake, check how to challenge the decision to stop your PIP. If your circ*mstances change again and you think you can get PIP again, call the DWP and tell them. They might agree to start your PIP claim again or they might tell you to make a new claim - check how to make a PIP claim.

Can PIP be awarded for life? ›

6.1 How long is PIP paid for? A PIP award can be indefinite but is usually for a fixed period. The length depends on an assessment of how likely it is that your daily living and mobility needs may change over time.

What are the 12 points for PIP assessment? ›

PIP Points Scores Daily Living Activities
  • Preparing food. ...
  • Taking nutrition. ...
  • Managing therapy or monitoring a health condition. ...
  • Washing and bathing. ...
  • Managing toilet needs or incontinence. ...
  • Dressing and undressing. ...
  • Communicating verbally. ...
  • Reading and understanding signs, symbols and words.

How long does a PIP appeal usually take? ›

It usually takes up to 6 months for an appeal to be heard by the tribunal. Your appeal might be delayed unless you: send any evidence as soon as you can before the hearing. arrive at the hearing on time (if you're attending)

What are the odds of winning the mandatory reconsideration PIP? ›

Just 19% of planned PIP review claimants end up with an increased award. The lesson, as always with the DWP, is to take nothing for granted. Even if your condition hasn't changed since your last award, ensure that you provide detailed evidence about how your condition affects you now.

Is PIP paid during appeal? ›

Will I get PIP during my reconsideration and appeal? You will not usually get any payments during a reconsideration and appeal of a PIP decision. If you are moving from DLA to PIP you will continue to get DLA for 4 weeks following the decision.

What is the PIP rate 2023? ›

For 2023, the daily living component of Personal Independence Payment (PIP) has increased to £101.75 for the enhanced rate and £68.10 for the standard rate. The mobility component has increased to £71.00 for the enhanced rate and £26.90 for the standard rate.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Delena Feil

Last Updated:

Views: 6416

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Delena Feil

Birthday: 1998-08-29

Address: 747 Lubowitz Run, Sidmouth, HI 90646-5543

Phone: +99513241752844

Job: Design Supervisor

Hobby: Digital arts, Lacemaking, Air sports, Running, Scouting, Shooting, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Delena Feil, I am a clean, splendid, calm, fancy, jolly, bright, faithful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.