Why Password Managers Don't Solve the Password Problem (2024)

One of the most common struggles people face in the digital age is managingtheir passwords. With the endless number of websites and online accounts thatrequire a unique login, it becomes way more difficult to remember all thedifferent passwords. A solution that has emerged to keep track of passwords inthe online world are password managers.

Problems with password managers

Password managers, such as Dashlane, LastPass, and 1Password, are tools thathelp people to create and manage unique passwords for their online accounts.These software and services offer a single and encrypted location where youcan store all your login credentials. Having a digital vault remember yourpasswords may seem like a blessing, but there are multiple problems withpasswords managers. Here are some of the major ones:

Problem 1: Low user adoption rates

One major problem with password managers is that they require users to installthe software on every device they use, add their credentials to the passwordmanager, and ensure that everything is properly synced. This can be acumbersome task for many people, leading to low user adoption rates of around20%. This low adoption rate is a problem for companies that rely on passwordmanagers for authentication, as it means that many of their users are stillusing weak, easily guessable passwords or reusing the same password acrossmultiple accounts.

Problem 2: Vulnerability to attacks

Additionally, password managers are often targeted by hackers. The recentsecurity incident at LastPass is just one example of this. While passwordmanagers do offer some protection against password-based attacks, they arestill vulnerable to other types of attacks, such as phishing or malware. If apassword manager's database is compromised, all the user's passwords are atrisk of being exposed.

Problem 3: Passwordless future

The business model of password managers relies on people continuing to usepasswords as the primary method of authentication for their online accounts.However, as online security continues to improve, the way we log in towebsites and online accounts is also evolving. More and more websites andservices are moving towards passwordless authentication methods, whicheliminate the need for passwords. These methods use biometric data or otherunique characteristics to verify a user's identity, such as one-time codessent via text or email. As these technologies become more widespread, it'slikely that we'll see even more websites and services adopting passwordlessauthentication in the future.

Passkeys as the solution

Passkeys as the new authentication standard offer comprehensive solutions tothe above-mentioned problems of password managers. Using biometric login likeFace ID, Touch ID and Windows Hello, they create a simple and convenientsolution that will boost adoption and never require a password again. Also,passkeys are the most secure authentication method since they rely on public-key cryptography, where a private key is stored on the users passkey deviceand a public key is stored on a dedicated server. Because the private keynever leaves the passkey device it is highly secure and resistant to anycybercriminal. Lastly, passkeys are already prepared for a passwordless futureas they rely on a technology that works completely without passwords, whilealso creating a promising business model.

The recent acquisition of Passage by 1Password shows that password managersare about to strengthen their passwordless capabilities in the passkeys area.Still, it is important to note that they require customers to install theirsoftware. This means that users must take the time to download and set up thepassword manager on all of their devices as well as requiring their users toremember a master password.

Corbado helps you to move towards the passwordless future and integratepasskeys

Instead of relying the burden of going passwordless to the users andrequiring them to install additional software, SaaS and e-commerce companiesshould take responsibility for implementing passwordless authentication. Byoffering passkeys as a central authentication method, companies can simplifythe login process for their users and increase security by eliminating theneed for passwords.

At Corbado, we are working on passwordless and passkey-centered authenticationsolutions that prioritize user experience. Our solution is designed to be easyto integrate and convenient for the user, while also providing strong securityagainst cyber threats.

Why Password Managers Don't Solve the Password Problem (2024)

FAQs

Why Password Managers Don't Solve the Password Problem? ›

Problems with password managers

What is wrong with the password manager? ›

Not all devices are secure enough. Hackers exploit the same vulnerability to get all of your logins in one attack. Password managers can be hacked if your device is infected with malware. In this case, typing the master password will get it recorded, and cybercriminals will gain full access to the data stored.

What is a weakness of password managers? ›

Poorly-protected managers:

Password managers can be a security threat if they do not encrypt their data. Hackers know that compromising a password manager is like getting the keys to the castle. Because of this a strong encryption must be in place to prevent access to your saved passwords.

What is the one catch with password managers? ›

Password manager programs are a target for hackers. It's not easy to login using multiple devices. If the main password is used/typed/saved on a computer with malware, your main password can compromise all your other passwords controlled by the PM - all your passwords are only as secure as your master password.

What is the downside of using a password manager? ›

A major possible downside to using a password manager is that if a hacker gains access to it, they will have access to all your passwords. This is why it's important to choose a reputable password manager, like C2 Password, that uses strong encryption and other security measures to protect your data.

Which password manager has never been hacked? ›

There are several password managers with better security, as LastPass has been breached. 1Password is an option as it has never been breached, and NordPass is also known for its strong security features.

Are password managers a single point of failure? ›

Although password managers have numerous benefits, they are also a single point of failure. This means that if an attacker compromises your password manager, they get all your passwords in one fell swoop.

Do security experts recommend password managers? ›

The ISO recommends four password managers that you can use in your daily life: 1Password, Apple's iCloud Keychain, BitWarden, KeePass, and LastPass (alphabetical order).

Has a password manager ever been hacked? ›

Unfortunately, password managers have been hacked before. OneLogin was hacked in 2017, and LastPass was breached in 2022. In March 2023, LastPass issued a statement that the breach resulted in unauthorized users gaining unencrypted access to customers' vault data, including information like usernames and passwords.

Is it better to use a password manager or your own password? ›

A password manager (or a web browser) can store all your passwords securely, so you don't have to worry about remembering them. This allows you to use unique, strong passwords for all your important accounts (rather than using the same password for all of them, which you should never do).

What is the easiest password manager for seniors? ›

We believe that NordPass, RoboForm, and Dashlane are the easiest password managers for seniors because they're intuitive, easy to use, and provide a variety of features that older adults will find useful.

What is most popular password manager? ›

The 4 best password managers
  • 1Password for most people.
  • Bitwarden for a free password manager.
  • Dashlane for a full internet security tool.
  • iCloud Keychain for Apple users.
Jan 19, 2024

Are password managers 100% safe? ›

Even the best password manager isn't perfect. No matter how well it has been designed, there's no such thing as 100% security so you should focus on minimizing the risks. One of the biggest flaws in a password manager's security architecture is you, the user.

Why use a password manager instead of browser? ›

Password managers use encryption methods to protect your passwords from hackers. This means that not even the owners of LastPass can access your saved passwords. In fact, in November 2022, LastPass was hacked, but hackers were not able to access stored passwords due to the company's encryption methods.

Why use a password manager vs browser? ›

The power of one dedicated password manager

All in all, browser-based password managers just don't make the cut. They don't allow you to switch browsers, use the same services on apps, securely share your credentials with others, customize generated passwords, or store information other than passwords.

How do I fix Google password manager? ›

Troubleshooting Tips for Google Password Manager
  1. Check if the password is associated with the right Google Account or not.
  2. Make sure you are using the latest version of Chrome and that your system is updated.
  3. Tidy up your passwords. ...
  4. Confirm that you are connected to the internet.

How do I fix Chrome password manager? ›

You can turn this option off or on at any time.
  1. On your computer, open Chrome.
  2. At the top right, select Profile Passwords . If you can't find the Passwords icon, at the top right, select More Passwords and autofill. Google Password Manager.
  3. On the left, select Settings.
  4. Turn Offer to save passwords on or off.

Is Chrome password manager not safe? ›

Zero-knowledge encryption is the reason dedicated password managers can keep your data safe without ever having access to your master password. “Google's password manager doesn't use zero-knowledge encryption,” stated Lurey. “In essence, Google can see everything you save.

Has 1Password ever been breached? ›

The password manager came forward after BeyondTrust and Cloudflare disclosed similar Okta environment breaches. All three victims claim no data was compromised.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Stevie Stamm

Last Updated:

Views: 5809

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Stevie Stamm

Birthday: 1996-06-22

Address: Apt. 419 4200 Sipes Estate, East Delmerview, WY 05617

Phone: +342332224300

Job: Future Advertising Analyst

Hobby: Leather crafting, Puzzles, Leather crafting, scrapbook, Urban exploration, Cabaret, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is Stevie Stamm, I am a colorful, sparkling, splendid, vast, open, hilarious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.