Pros and Cons of Independent Real Estate Brokerage vs Franchise (2024)

Want to Start a Business in Real Estate but Can’t Make up Your Mind How?

If you are considering starting a business in real estate, the first question you should ask yourself is: do I want to do this alone or would I rather join an established company as a franchisee?

The answer to that question will determine whether you should go independent and open your own real estate broker enterprise, or if franchising is the better route.

In this article, we explain the pros and cons of starting an independent brokerage vs. buying a franchise brokerage.

Pros and cons of a real estate franchise

There are many advantages provided by franchise brokers, but there are disadvantages too. Whether the disadvantages outweigh the advantages depends on individual circ*mstances and characteristics.

The pros

  • Brand recognition

When you operate a franchise, you benefit from people’s perception of the brand – a business that can be trusted because they have built their reputation over many years.

  • Out-of-the-box tools

For example, the franchisor provides all the necessary marketing materials, including brochures, website content, and marketing tools.

  • Education resources

Franchisees are given access to training, development, and coaching from professionals who have been trained by the franchisers. This may include the franchisors themselves, or senior people within the company.

  • A support system of experts

A strong and supportive network that can help you to grow your business, improve your skills, and build a high-performing team. This can also act as a referral network.

  • Attract the best agents

The strength of national franchises is being a recognized brand in the industry. As well as the customer benefits of brand recognition of a franchised company, this will help attract high performers to your business – the agents and brokers who will help you be successful.

The cons

  • Expensive fees

Buying a real estate franchise can be expensive. You’ll have the initial fee, the costs of premises and equipment, and ongoing franchise fees to pay (monthly fees and royalties).

  • Training resources may be basic

While you may benefit from the training provided by the franchisor, the training may be basic. If this is the case, you may find yourself wishing to invest in external training, at your own expense.

  • Inflexibility

As a franchisee, you are limited to how you run your business by the terms of the franchise contract. The franchisor is operating a large business, and their way of working must be replicated across all franchisees.

Pros and cons of independent brokers

As an independent broker, you can be more flexible with your business, but you will lose the support of a national brand. Here we outline the main pros and cons of starting your own independent real estate brokerage.

The pros

One of the biggest benefits of being an independent brokerage is that you are not limited by a franchisor’s guidelines. You can build your business according to your own vision and values.

  • Independence and flexibility

As an independent broker, you have complete freedom and flexibility to work from your home or anywhere else you want. You can set your own hours and priorities, and make decisions without referring to the franchisor.

  • Lower costs

You may have lower startup costs, with a greater ability to choose where to locate. You won’t need to pay an initial franchise fee, and there are no ongoing charges and commissions to pay to the franchisor.

  • Local focus

A national real estate brokerage will naturally have a national focus, but the real estate market is very localized. As an independent, you can focus on your local market, and adjust strategy and marketing accordingly.

The Cons

  • A lack of resources

As an independent, you won’t have access to the training, marketing tools, support, and network that a national brand can offer you. This will make it harder to compete against bigger real estate companies and grow your business.

  • Lower scale

With less access to resources and no brand name behind you, it may be difficult to compete against companies that have much larger customer bases and budgets.

Your choice between franchise and independent real estate brokerage

The choice of how to start and operate as a real estate agent is not an easy one to make. In this article, we have only been able to scratch the surface of the advantages and disadvantages of each business model. There is a lot more to think about under each heading before deciding whether starting a business or buying a franchise is best for you.

In summary, a real estate franchise offers you a chance to start your own business. The franchisor will give you marketing materials, training, and experience. As a franchisee, you also benefit from the strength of a larger company behind you.

On the other hand, if you are someone who loves being creative and wants to have more control over your business, then going into business as an independent real estate agent might be for you.

How do you best decide? The first step is to take our franchise aptitude test now. It only takes a few minutes, and it will provide you with highly valuable and actionable insight. After this, you’ll be much better equipped to discuss your individual and unique position with the franchise brokers you can trust: New Ground Consulting.

Error: Please complete all required fields!

Pros and Cons of Independent Real Estate Brokerage vs Franchise (1)

We will never spam or share your email with 3rd parties, promise!

Pros and Cons of Independent Real Estate Brokerage vs Franchise (2024)

FAQs

Pros and Cons of Independent Real Estate Brokerage vs Franchise? ›

Franchise brokers are limited on how they operate, brand, and market themselves. Independent brokers have the freedom and flexibility to run their own business, develop their own voice, and grant their agents more autonomy. Education. Franchisees experiment less compared to their independent counterparts.

Is it better to be a franchise or independent? ›

Franchises offer a proven blueprint for success, brand recognition, and ongoing support, while independent businesses provide creative freedom, unlimited potential, and personal fulfillment. Assess your goals, risk tolerance, financial capabilities, and desired level of support before making your choice.

Are real estate franchises worth it? ›

The Benefits of Purchasing a Real Estate Franchise

The idea behind purchasing a franchise is having a proven model and systems that will allow you to grow your brokerage faster, and with less risk, than you could on your own. Yes, the upfront costs can be steep, but the benefits and reduced risk can be appealing.

What are the pros and cons of being a real estate broker? ›

The Pros and Cons of a Real Estate Career
  • Pro #1. Achieving Freedom. ...
  • Pro #2. Feeling Responsible. ...
  • Pro #3. Being Respected. ...
  • Pro #4. Excitement. ...
  • Con #1. Having Nothing to Do. ...
  • Con #2. Doing the Wrong Things. ...
  • Con #3. Weird Working Hours. ...
  • Con #4. Irregular Income.

What is one fundamental difference between real estate brokerage and business brokerage? ›

Business brokerage is different from real estate brokerage in five ways: (1) business brokerage usually involves assets other than real estate, such as personal property and good will, (2) the value of an established business may differ from the value of the real estate, (3) unlike real estate, the value of a business ...

What is more effective franchising or independent business? ›

Franchising offers the advantage of an established brand, support, and higher success rates, while independent businesses provide flexibility, unlimited growth potential, and higher profit margins.

Why independent business is better than franchise? ›

The pros, or benefits of running your own business alone rather than franchising include: Full control of branding. Full control of service offerings and changes to the business model. No royalty payments or franchise fee.

What is the fastest-growing real estate franchise? ›

The fastest-growing franchises in this year's report, seeing double-digit growth in the number of U.S. offices since 2019, were Nest Realty, Flat Rate Realty, and NextHome. United Real Estate, HomeSmart, and NextHome—all relative newcomers—saw big gains in the number of U.S. agents and brokers.

Who is the #1 real estate franchise in the world? ›

LAGUNA NIGUEL, Calif., Jan. 18, 2024 /PRNewswire/ -- Realty ONE Group, a modern, purpose-driven lifestyle brand and ONE of the fastest-growing franchisors in the world, is the #1 real estate brand for the third year in a row on Entrepreneur's highly competitive 2024 Franchise 500® ranking.

What is the success rate of a franchise? ›

Studies in the market have estimated that failure rates for franchises can be as high as 50%, while others studies show lower rates around 20%. With a range like this, It's important you research the potential risks of starting a franchise before deciding to invest.

What do realtors struggle with the most? ›

5 of the Biggest Real Estate Challenges + How Agents Can Overcome Them
  • Fierce Competition. ...
  • Long Hours. ...
  • Time Management. ...
  • It Feels Like a Thankless Job.
Nov 18, 2023

Why do real estate brokers make so much money? ›

Realtors earn more from quick sales, high transaction prices, and maximum commission. They have incentives to share new listings with a few colleagues in advance, while steering buyers away from homes with discounted commissions.

Why a broker is better than an agent? ›

The reason that brokers can work independently or supervise other agents is that they're allowed to handle certain financial and legal steps in the transaction process that agents cannot. Brokers can move money in and out of escrow accounts and mediate legal disputes that arise from the transaction.

Do you need a brokerage firm? ›

Personalized attention and extra support can be nice, but you don't need a stockbroker to invest in stocks. You could take a DIY approach with an online brokerage, or allow a robo-advisor to do the work for you.

What are the 2 main differences between agents and brokers? ›

The agent may represent either the buyer or the seller. A real estate broker does the same job as an agent but is licensed to work independently and may employ agents. Brokers are paid on commission but also get a cut of the commissions of agents who work for them.

What is the difference between a broker and a brokerage? ›

Brokers mostly get a commission from a portion of the customer's purchase although sometimes they are paid a flat fee of the transaction. A brokerage is the commission amount that the broker gets for being an intermediator for the deal carried out.

What is the main disadvantage of a franchise? ›

For most franchisees, the most frustrating disadvantage that they face is that they must follow the restrictions laid out in the franchise agreement. The franchisor can exert a degree of control over the majority of the franchise business and decisions made by the franchisee.

What are the disadvantages of being a franchise owner? ›

Franchisees have limited control over the daily operations of their business. You will be required to comply with existing management operations, procedures, training standards, and hours of operation.

What is a negative of owning a franchise? ›

The franchisee is not completely independent. Franchisees are required to operate their businesses according to the procedures and restrictions set forth by the franchisor in the franchisee agreement. These restrictions usually include the products or services which can be offered, pricing and geographic territory.

Is it worth it to become a franchise owner? ›

The average annual income of a franchise owner whose business has been open between two and 10 years is $130,000, a survey conducted by Franchise Business Review revealed. Most franchises provide extensive training and ongoing support. You get guidance on everything from marketing to operational best practices.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terrell Hackett

Last Updated:

Views: 5468

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (72 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terrell Hackett

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Suite 453 459 Gibson Squares, East Adriane, AK 71925-5692

Phone: +21811810803470

Job: Chief Representative

Hobby: Board games, Rock climbing, Ghost hunting, Origami, Kabaddi, Mushroom hunting, Gaming

Introduction: My name is Terrell Hackett, I am a gleaming, brainy, courageous, helpful, healthy, cooperative, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.