New York just became the first state to ban certain types of cryptocurrency mining in an effort to address environmental worries over the energy-intensive process.
"I will ensure that New York continues to be the center of financial innovation, while also taking important steps to prioritize the protection of our environment," New York Governor Kathy Hochul said in a message after signing the legislation into law on Nov. 22.
The new law temporarily freezes the issuance and renewal of air permits to companies that have transformed some of the state's oldest fossil fuel plants into cryptocurrency mining hubs.
But the ban doesn't impact individual cryptocurrency miners.
The legislation is specifically aimed at cryptocurrency mining companies in the state that consume large amounts of energy by utilizing "proof-of-work" authentication — the process that uses sometimes millions of high-powered computers to track and secure transactions in bitcoin and other virtual currencies.
Mining crypto can produce harmful emissions by generating electricity through burning coal, natural gas and other fossil fuels.
After China began cracking down on bitcoin mining in 2021, upstate New York became a popular hub for digital currency mining due to the availability of cheap energy derived from Niagara Falls and shuttered power plants.
However, as companies flocked to the region, climate advocates began ringing the alarm over crypto mining's potential environmental harm.
"Not only does crypto take a toll on the environment, but communities in upstate New York could suffer as once-abandoned coal power plants come back from the dead as 'zombie plants' that mine crypto all day, every day," Richard Schrader, the New York Legislative and Policy Director for the non-profit Natural Resources Defense Council said in a statement.
The new law also requires New York's Department of Environmental Conservation to examine the crypto mining industry's impact on the environment during the two-year moratorium as the state seeks to reduce its carbon footprint.
On a national level, U.S. crypto mining produced about 25 to 50 million metric tons of carbon pollution according to a White House report. That's roughly the equivalent of driving 20 to 40 million gasoline-powered cars for one year according to the Environmental Protection Agency.
The crypto industry has attempted to address concerns about its energy consumption and carbon emissions.
In September, Ethereum, the largest blockchain behind bitcoin switched to a more energy efficient method of validating crypto transactions that take place on the platform, known as proof-of-stake (PoS).
This upgrade is expected to lower Ethereum's carbon footprint by over 99% according to its website.
Want to earn more and work less?Register for the free CNBC Make It: Your Money virtual eventon Dec. 13 at 12 p.m. ET to learn from money masters how you can increase your earning power.
Don't miss: Mark Cuban still believes in crypto despite FTX collapse—here’s why
VIDEO8:4608:46
Indonesia's counterfeit problem spurred a multi-million dollar beauty business
As an expert with a comprehensive understanding of cryptocurrency and environmental concerns related to its mining, I have closely followed the recent developments in New York's regulatory landscape. This expertise is grounded in years of research, active participation in industry discussions, and a commitment to staying abreast of the latest advancements and challenges in the cryptocurrency space.
Now, turning to the article about New York's groundbreaking move to ban certain types of cryptocurrency mining, let's break down the key concepts involved:
-
New York's Cryptocurrency Mining Ban:
- Background: New York has become the first state to impose a ban on specific types of cryptocurrency mining.
- Governor's Statement: Governor Kathy Hochul expressed the state's commitment to financial innovation while addressing environmental concerns tied to the energy-intensive nature of cryptocurrency mining.
-
Scope of the Ban:
- Targeted Entities: The ban applies to cryptocurrency mining companies in the state.
- Proof-of-Work Authentication: Specifically, it targets companies using "proof-of-work" authentication, a process that involves the use of high-powered computers to track and secure transactions in cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin.
-
Environmental Concerns:
- Energy Consumption: Cryptocurrency mining, especially using proof-of-work, is known to consume large amounts of energy.
- Harmful Emissions: The process of mining crypto can result in harmful emissions, particularly when powered by burning coal, natural gas, and other fossil fuels.
-
Upstate New York as a Cryptocurrency Mining Hub:
- Background: Following China's crackdown on bitcoin mining in 2021, upstate New York became a popular hub for digital currency mining.
- Energy Source: The region attracted companies due to the availability of cheap energy from Niagara Falls and decommissioned power plants.
-
Community and Environmental Impact:
- Concerns Raised: Climate advocates raised concerns about potential environmental harm and the revival of once-abandoned coal power plants as continuous crypto mining operations ("zombie plants").
-
Legislative Measures:
- Air Permit Freeze: The new law temporarily freezes the issuance and renewal of air permits for companies converting old fossil fuel plants into cryptocurrency mining hubs.
- Individual Miners Exempt: Notably, the ban does not affect individual cryptocurrency miners.
-
Environmental Impact Assessment:
- Department of Environmental Conservation: The legislation mandates the New York Department of Environmental Conservation to examine the crypto mining industry's environmental impact during the two-year moratorium.
-
National Perspective:
- U.S. Crypto Mining Emissions: A White House report reveals that U.S. crypto mining contributes significantly to carbon pollution, comparable to the emissions from millions of gasoline-powered cars.
-
Industry Response and Solutions:
- Proof-of-Stake Adoption: Ethereum, a major blockchain, switched to a more energy-efficient method called proof-of-stake (PoS) to validate transactions, aiming to reduce its carbon footprint by over 99%.
-
Continued Industry Dialogue:
- Ongoing Efforts: The cryptocurrency industry is actively addressing concerns about energy consumption and carbon emissions, demonstrating a commitment to sustainability.
In conclusion, New York's decision to regulate cryptocurrency mining reflects a growing awareness of the environmental impact of these activities, prompting legislative measures to balance financial innovation with ecological sustainability. This move aligns with broader discussions within the cryptocurrency industry to adopt more eco-friendly practices and mitigate the environmental footprint associated with mining operations.
