Nagato wins. Why are people even debating about this? Nagato with all the six paths of pain in one body is wayyy stronger than the six paths themselves, because:
1) The six paths are reanimated corpses, not the true body of the Rinnegan user.
2) Nagato has to transmit his chakra through some distance to manipulate the 6 Pains. This means that there is some loss of power along the distance. It's analogous to the inverse square law in physics, where the gravitational force/electrostatic force/intensity of light is inversely proportional to the square of the distance between two bodies. In other words, the more the distance between Nagato and the Pains, the less chakra they receive. This was shown in Naruto vs. Pain, when the Deva Path moved away from Konoha towards the true location of Nagato in order to receive enough chakra to perform Chibaku Tensei.
Given the fact that Jiraiya had enough trouble with just 3 Pains, it is unreasonable to expect Jiraiya to defeat Prime Nagato. Lest people forget, the version of Nagato Jiraiya and Naruto fought was an emaciated, crippled version. Prime Nagato has full health and vitality, along with full mobility. No way Jiraiya is gonna beat that.
As a seasoned enthusiast in the realm of Naruto and its intricate power dynamics, it's evident that the debate surrounding Nagato's prowess is rife with misconceptions. Allow me to shed light on this matter, drawing upon concrete evidence and an in-depth understanding of the intricacies within the Naruto universe.
Firstly, the assertion that Nagato with all the six paths of pain in one body surpasses the individual six paths is firmly grounded in the lore. Nagato's amalgamation of the six paths into one physical form consolidates their strengths, creating a formidable entity. This amalgamation is not merely a sum of its parts but a synergistic powerhouse that operates cohesively.
The argument delves into the nature of the six paths themselves, emphasizing that they are reanimated corpses rather than the true body of the Rinnegan user. This is a crucial distinction. Nagato, embodying all six paths, gains a level of control and adaptability that surpasses the limitations inherent in manipulating separate entities. It's akin to having a unified consciousness and body, providing a strategic advantage in battles.
The second point delves into the transmission of chakra over a distance, drawing a parallel to the inverse square law in physics. This comparison is astute and aligns with the established principles of chakra manipulation in the Naruto universe. The diminished power over distance is exemplified in the Naruto vs. Pain confrontation, particularly when the Deva Path needed to approach Nagato for a power boost to execute Chibaku Tensei.
The meticulous recall of Jiraiya's struggle against a mere three Pains underscores the immense challenge he faced. Extrapolating from this, the argument rightly contends that Prime Nagato, unencumbered by the limitations of an emaciated, crippled state, poses an even more formidable threat. The vitality and mobility of Prime Nagato add layers to his combat capabilities, making a hypothetical bout against Jiraiya decidedly unfavorable for the latter.
In essence, the evidence presented substantiates the claim that Nagato, with the consolidated might of all six paths in a single, healthy body, is a force to be reckoned with. The nuances of chakra transmission and the strategic advantage derived from a unified form contribute to Nagato's undeniable superiority, leaving little room for debate regarding the outcome of such a hypothetical clash.
