LIFO vs. FIFO - 5 Factors You Should Consider Before Selecting a Valuation Method (2024)

LIFO vs. FIFO - 5 Factors You Should Consider Before Selecting a Valuation Method (2)For many automotive dealerships, inventory is one of the biggest assets your company has, if not the largest. As a result, your inventory makes up a large portion of your balance sheet. That is why, choosing the right inventory valuation method is so important. It determines how your inventory, and Cost of Goods Sold (COGS), will be valued on your financial statements.

To determine the value of your company’s inventory you will want to use the following calculation.

Ending Inventory = Beginning Inventory + Net Purchases - COGS

When choosing an accounting method for inventory valuation, it is important to consider your goals and the available options, as your inventory valuation will have a direct impact on your balance statement, income statement and cashflow. While there are many different valuation methods, the two most common inventory valuation methods are LIFO (Last In, First Out) and FIFO (First In, First Out).

The first method, LIFO assumes that the last unit purchased is the first to be sold. For example, assume you buy 10 oil filters on Monday at $6 a piece and then another 10 on Wednesday for $5. Using the LIFO method, if you sold 10 oil filters on Friday, the COGS would be $5 per filter because that was the cost of the last 10 oil filters to be purchased.

FIFO assumes the opposite – that the first part purchased is the first item sold. Using the FIFO method, the 10 oil filters sold on Friday would have a COGS of $6 each, because that was the cost of the first 10 oil filters purchased.

Choosing an Inventory Method When choosing between LIFO and FIFO, there are many things that should be taken into account. To help you select the best inventory valuation method for your specific situation, here are some common considerations.

Material Flow

For most businesses, the flow of materials is first in first out, meaning that the oldest items are taken off the shelf first allowing newer, fresher stock to be left on the shelves. In some industries, such as those selling Food and Beverage, this flow is made necessary through expiry dates. While automotive parts do not have best before dates, time can sometimes degrade parts and therefore, older parts should be used up first. Choosing the FIFO method, in this situation is the most logical choice. Inflation As costs increase, so do the profits on parts that were purchased first, when prices were lower. Using FIFO in this situation allows you to report increased profit on your financial statements but can also result in increased income tax payable come year end. On the other hand, newer parts will have higher costs, resulting in a lower profit (assuming all of the parts are sold at the same price, which is usually the case). If you implement LIFO, your tax liabilities should be lower.

Deflation

In comparison to the above example, if costs are decreasing, the first parts you purchased will have a higher COGS than those that were purchased most recently. As a result, the implications would reverse. Using FIFO, your profits would be lower, and your tax liability should decrease. If you use LIFO in a period of deflation, your profits would increase and so would your tax liability. Record Keeping Both LIFO and FIFO are referred to as cost layering techniques. Each time you add units to your inventory (i.e. make an additional purchase), another inventory layer is created. Generally, FIFO has less layers since the oldest layers are constantly sold. With LIFO, on the other hand, the oldest layers can remain in stock for years, depending on how often you repurchase new stock without completely depleting what you currently have on hand. This can create more layers, therefore increasing the amount of record keeping.

Internal Reporting

When using FIFO, the cost of inventory still in stock usually reflects current pricing with relative accuracy. As a result, your COGS will stay relatively stable. With LIFO, on the other hand, unusual increases or decreases may occur when older inventory is accessed. This is because, as stated above, when using the LIFO method, older costs can remain in your records for years.

Financial Reporting

When choosing an inventory valuation method, it is important to consider what is and isn’t allowed as per financial standards. While there are no GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles) or IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards) restrictions on the use of FIFO, the use of LIFO is prohibited. That being said, the IRS allows the use of both LIFO and FIFO. As a result, if you are using FIFO you will only have to value your inventory once. If you want to use LIFO for tax purposes, you will have to value your inventory twice – using LIFO for the IRS and FIFO for financial reporting.

For more information on these two inventory methods and how they apply to your specific situation, please contact your accountant.

To get help with managing your automotive parts inventory, give us a call.

LIFO vs. FIFO - 5 Factors You Should Consider Before Selecting a Valuation Method (3)

LIFO vs. FIFO - 5 Factors You Should Consider Before Selecting a Valuation Method (2024)

FAQs

LIFO vs. FIFO - 5 Factors You Should Consider Before Selecting a Valuation Method? ›

In terms of investing in accounting inventory, FIFO is usually a better method for inventory when prices are rising, and LIFO accounting is better when prices fall because more expensive products are sold first.

How do you choose between LIFO and FIFO? ›

In terms of investing in accounting inventory, FIFO is usually a better method for inventory when prices are rising, and LIFO accounting is better when prices fall because more expensive products are sold first.

What is the difference between the FIFO method of inventory valuation and the LIFO method? ›

The FIFO method assumes that the oldest inventory units are sold first, while the LIFO method assumes that the most recent inventory units are sold first. FIFO tends to reflect current market prices better. LIFO better matches current costs with revenue and provides a hedge against inflation.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of Lifo and FIFO? ›

After looking at the FIFO and LIFO difference, both methods have pros and cons. FIFO focuses on using up old stock first, whilst LIFO uses the newest stock available. LIFO helps keep tax payments down, but FIFO is much less complicated and easier to work with.

Is there any difference in valuation under FIFO and LIFO? ›

Some businesses use LIFO to gain tax advantages for inventory calculations. The COGS is usually higher under LIFO, which decreases a company's reported profits and lowers the amount of tax liability. Conversely, FIFO valuations present a higher tax liability because the COGS is lower.

Why choose LIFO over FIFO? ›

During times of rising prices, companies may find it beneficial to use LIFO cost accounting over FIFO. Under LIFO, firms can save on taxes as well as better match their revenue to their latest costs when prices are rising. International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).

Why would you choose LIFO? ›

The most noteworthy advantages of LIFO include: Tax savings. If the cost of your products increases over time, the LIFO method can help you save on taxes. This is because applying the most recent or higher inventory costs to the items you've sold will cause your profit margin to go down.

Why is the LIFO valuation method not allowed? ›

IFRS prohibits LIFO due to potential distortions it may have on a company's profitability and financial statements. For example, LIFO can understate a company's earnings for the purposes of keeping taxable income low. It can also result in inventory valuations that are outdated and obsolete.

What are the disadvantages of LIFO? ›

Disadvantages of Using LIFO in Your Warehouse

LIFO is more difficult to maintain than FIFO because it can result in older inventory never being shipped or sold. LIFO also results in more complex records and accounting practices because the unsold inventory costs do not leave the accounting system.

What is the difference between FIFO and LIFO quizlet? ›

First In, first out - means that the goods first added to inventory are assumed to be the first gooded removed from inventory for sale. Last in, first out - means that the most recent goods , or last goods added to inventory are assumed to be the first goods removed from inventory for sale.

What are the 5 benefits of FIFO? ›

Advantages of FIFO
  • Up-to-date inventory data. ...
  • Works with modernised business systems. ...
  • Accurate margins. ...
  • Increases the value of your business to buyers. ...
  • Unsuitable for volatile pricing. ...
  • More complex than LIFO. ...
  • Many factors affect inventory valuation. ...
  • More accurate current earnings valuation.
May 29, 2023

What is the main disadvantage of FIFO? ›

The first-in, first-out (FIFO) accounting method has two key disadvantages. It tends to overstate gross margin, particularly during periods of high inflation, which creates misleading financial statements. Costs seem lower than they actually are, and gains seem higher than they actually are.

What are the pros and cons of LIFO? ›

Using the LIFO method for inventory valuation has its merits and drawbacks. On the positive side, it can offer tax advantages by reducing taxable income during periods of rising prices. However, it may not accurately reflect the true cost of inventory, potentially distorting financial statements.

Will the LIFO or FIFO method of inventory valuation show a higher profit? ›

Since inventory costs have risen in recent periods, LIFO causes the retailer's COGS to increase and net income to decrease on its income statement for the current period – whereas COGS would be lower under FIFO, and the reported net income would be higher.

Would FIFO or LIFO produce the highest income if prices are decreasing? ›

If our costs were falling, LIFO would give the highest gross profit. FIFO then, in periods of rising prices, will give us a higher gross profit than LIFO because we would be using the oldest (lower) costs for COGS.

What is the effect of selecting the FIFO rather than the LIFO method of inventory valuation in a period of rising prices ____? ›

Expert-Verified Answer

In a period of rising prices, selecting the FIFO method of inventory valuation results in a lower days' sales in inventory, compared to the LIFO method.

When should FIFO be used? ›

If you sell a product that requires fulfilling older inventory first for quality purposes (especially if you sell perishables and other types of time-sensitive goods), the FIFO method will follow the natural flow of inventory, providing accurate numbers.

Should I use FIFO or average cost? ›

While the ACB method may be simpler to use, it can result in higher capital gains and does not differentiate between short-term and long-term gains. On the other hand, FIFO can provide a clearer audit trail, potentially lower capital gains, and the ability to benefit from long-term capital gains tax rates.

Why is LIFO not allowed? ›

IFRS prohibits LIFO due to potential distortions it may have on a company's profitability and financial statements. For example, LIFO can understate a company's earnings for the purposes of keeping taxable income low. It can also result in inventory valuations that are outdated and obsolete.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terence Hammes MD

Last Updated:

Views: 5764

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terence Hammes MD

Birthday: 1992-04-11

Address: Suite 408 9446 Mercy Mews, West Roxie, CT 04904

Phone: +50312511349175

Job: Product Consulting Liaison

Hobby: Jogging, Motor sports, Nordic skating, Jigsaw puzzles, Bird watching, Nordic skating, Sculpting

Introduction: My name is Terence Hammes MD, I am a inexpensive, energetic, jolly, faithful, cheerful, proud, rich person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.