INSIDER TRADING: LEGAL OR ILLEGAL? | Article | Chambers and Partners (2024)

It is a term used commonly in the securities market and usually relates to illegal conduct. However, insider trading can be both be legal and illegal. In generic terms, insider trading means buying and selling of stocks and shares based on significant information which is publicly not available. Apart from creating a biased field which disadvantages other investors, insider trading by corporate employees breach their utmost responsibility to work in the best interest of the shareholders. The Corporate Lawyers in Dubai will assist the readers in understanding the legal consequences of insider trading in accordance with UAE laws.

The legality of insider trading depends on the time when the insider’s official trades the information. Analyzing a global perspective, in most countries, insider trading is not illegal if the information provided by key personnel of a company in a way which does not allow an individual to take advantage of insider information. Importantly, the higher officials of a company are not restricted to trade in their company’s shares as contrary to the general rules; it would be unfair to prevent these officials making company’s significant decision from investing in stocks. The term insider trading is used to allude to an act in which an insider or a related party exchanges non-public confidential information of an entity amid his performance of his duties at the company. Illicit trading in this way incorporates tipping others when you have any sort of sensitive information not available publicly. Not only directors can be convicted under such offence, but the law can also penalize the brokers as well as the family members to misuse the information.

The Legal Framework

Federal Law Number 4 of 2000 concerning the Emirates Securities and Commodities Authority (the SCA Law) regulates and prohibits the act of insider trading. The regulatory authorities governing such acts are the Central Bank, Securities Commodities Authority (SCA) Department of Trade and Finance, police and Public Prosecution. Whereas, the Dubai International Financial Free Zone (DIFC), the financial free zone in Dubai has a separate central regulatory authority named Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA) who regulates the economic activities of the companies established within DIFC.

Article 37 of the SCA Law though does not wholly define the act of insider trading, however, consider any exploitation of confidential non-public information which might cause severe impact on the price of the securities is prohibited, and such actions will be null and void. The Law allows higher officials or members of the board of the company whose shares are listed in stock exchange to carry out transactions in securities if:

  1. They publicly provide the information pertaining to the acquisition or sale. The report shall include all the details regarding the price or quantities or any other information relevant for the market;
  2. They sought approval on every stage from the board of directors.

In lieu of the foregoing, any activity which is not in line with the aforementioned procedure will be declared as null or void (Article 37). The law further restricts any corporate official who has received any private and non-public information of the company to deal in securities, which he has received due to his position in the entity, reference to Article 39. All the corporate officials including the higher management are restricted to disclose private information or spread rumours about the acquisition or sale of shares. Any activity in this regard will be declared null and void.

The law subsequently provides for penal provisions on violation of any regulation as mentioned under Article 41 which states that any breach of the foregoing clauses, an individual subjected to insider trading will be imprisoned for a period of not less than 3 months and not more than 3 years and shall be liable for a fine ranging between AED 100,000 to AED 1 Million. A specific breach of Article 38 will attract imprisonment for a period not more than 3 years and a fine not more than AED 1 Million.

Recent Developments

Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange (ADX) has banned the insider trading until the companies disclose the financial statements. The concerned decision was to take in consonance with Article 14 of the Securities and Commodities Authorities’ Decision Number 1 of the year 2001 concerning the regulations on trading, clearing transfer of ownership and custody of securities. The concerned article states that the any employee or corporate official including the chairman and the board members who have access to insider information are prohibited either themselves or through others to trade in securities of the same company or any of its subsidiaries or sister companies, if they are listed on stock exchange, during a period of 15 days prior to disclosing the financial statements of the company until they are revealed.

ADX has further through the concerned circular, requested all the public listed companies to update their insiders’ data urgently and regularly on their websites. The concerned disclosures or transparency regulations either promulgated by SCA, ADX or Dubai Financial Market (DFM) imposes a duty to report to the directors of the board any insiders’ information whose securities are listed publicly.

INSIDER TRADING: LEGAL OR ILLEGAL? | Article | Chambers and Partners (2024)

FAQs

What insider trading is legal? ›

Insider transactions are legal if the insider makes a trade and reports it to the Securities and Exchange Commission, but insider trading is illegal when the material information is still non-public.

Who can be held liable for insider trading? ›

Under the classical theory of insider trading, insiders who “tip” friends about material non-public information which may influence the company's publicly traded stock price may be liable.

Can a spouse be charged with insider trading? ›

If your spouse intentionally shared confidential information about the acquisition, expecting to benefit from your trading profits, they are equally guilty of insider trading. This constitutes “tipping” and is illegal.

What are the three types of insider trading? ›

Classic Insider Trading: Buying or selling assets based on important non-public information. Tipper-Tippee Trading: An insider gives others access to confidential information so they can trade using it. Trading During Blackout Periods: Insider trading during times when particular people are barred from trading.

What are the 4 elements of insider trading? ›

The Supreme Court proscribed 4 elements to prove insider trading under the misappropriation theory, 1) a lie or deception 2) a transgression of a fiduciary obligation 3) the use of secret information in relation to a securities transaction 4) willfulness by the defendant.

Is insider trading legal and acceptable? ›

Trading by specific insiders, such as employees, is commonly permitted as long as it does not rely on material information not available to the general public. Many jurisdictions require that such trading be reported so that the transactions can be monitored.

How do people get caught for insider trading? ›

The Securities and Exchange Commission plays a pivotal role in detecting and prosecuting insider trading. The agency monitors trading activities and investigates unusual spikes in trading volume or price changes that precede significant corporate events, such as mergers or earnings reports.

Is insider trading hard to prove? ›

This prosecutorial choice may have been due to how the law is written. “It is incredibly difficult to prove an insider trading case,” said Daniel Taylor, a forensic accounting professor at the University of Pennsylvania. “Congress has never actually defined what insider trading was and explicitly outlawed it.”

What is the burden of proof for insider trading? ›

This means that the act of insider trading does not have to be proven beyond reasonable doubt, as is the standard in criminal cases. Rather, presenting evidence which leads to the conclusion that the probability of the person to have committed the act is higher than not is enough to prove insider trading has happened.

Does insider trading apply to family members? ›

Close family relationships carry with them a duty to the source of the information, and may therefore give rise to insider trading liability.

Are family members considered insiders? ›

Types of Insiders

If they share the information with a friend, family member, or business associate and the person who receives the tip exchanges stock in the company, they are also an insider.

Who is a tippee in insider trading? ›

BACKGROUND ON TIPPEE INSIDER TRADING

Tippee liability for insider trading—that is, liability for non-insider recipients of “tips” of confidential information who trade on that information—was first recognized by the Supreme Court in Dirks v. SEC. [

Are insider trades illegal? ›

Insider trading is the selling or purchase of stocks and other securities based on non-public, material insider information. People found guilty of Illegal insider trading can receive up to 20 years of jail time and a $5 million fine.

What are examples of illegal insider trading? ›

For example, suppose the CEO of a publicly traded firm inadvertently discloses their company's quarterly earnings while getting a haircut. If the hairdresser takes this information and trades on it, that is considered illegal insider trading, and the SEC may take action.

Am I allowed to buy stock in the company I work for? ›

In addition to the usual mutual funds and ETFs offered in 401(k) plans, employers will offer employees the option of investing in company stock. Matching contributions may also be offered in the form of company stock. Just be aware that stock purchases in a 401(k) plan might come with some restrictions.

Is it insider trading if you overhear? ›

The individual charged with insider trading must have been aware that the information was material and nonpublic. For example, if you overhear a conversation on a train but have no knowledge that it is insider information, you cannot be convicted if you act on this information.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rev. Leonie Wyman

Last Updated:

Views: 5582

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rev. Leonie Wyman

Birthday: 1993-07-01

Address: Suite 763 6272 Lang Bypass, New Xochitlport, VT 72704-3308

Phone: +22014484519944

Job: Banking Officer

Hobby: Sailing, Gaming, Basketball, Calligraphy, Mycology, Astronomy, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Rev. Leonie Wyman, I am a colorful, tasty, splendid, fair, witty, gorgeous, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.