Don't play the 'audit lottery.' These are the top reasons your tax return may be flagged by the IRS (2024)

Getty Images

If you're among the millions of Americans scrambling to meet the tax deadline, it's critical to avoid errors that may flag your return or even trigger an IRS audit.

The agency has processed more than 78.8 million returns as of March 25, the IRS reported Friday, including nearly 58 million refunds.

But with the tax agency still wading through a sizable backlog of returns, it's better to reduce contact by filing yours correctly and avoiding any mistakes that may invite scrutiny, experts say.

The IRS closed 452,515 individual audits during its fiscal 2020, about 0.29% of the roughly 157 million individual income tax returns filed, according tothe agency.

"Some people play the audit lottery, meaning they'll do whatever they want and know that the chances of getting caught are slim," said John Apisa, a CPA and partner at PKF O'Connor Davies LLP. "That's not a good philosophy to have, though."

While there's typically a three-year statute of limitations for an IRS audit, with extensions in some cases, there's no time limit on how long the agency can pursue fraud or non-filers.

One of the first cues may be trying to claim too many credits or deductions compared with your income, tax experts say.

Don't play the 'audit lottery.' These are the top reasons your tax return may be flagged by the IRS (1)

watch now

VIDEO1:2901:29

What your monthly budget will be if you retire with $500,000

The IRS uses software with a numeric score for each return, with higher scores more likely to spark an audit, said certified financial planner David Silversmith, a CPA and senior manager of PKF O'Connor Davies in New York.

The system estimates the appropriate range for each deduction or credit by income level, and if write-offs are outside that range, scores may increase, he said.

For example, $90,000 of earnings with $60,000 in charitable deductions will alarm the system, said Apisa.

You're also likely to get flagged if the submitted tax forms don't match your reported income, triggering an automated notice, said Preeti Shah, a CFP and CPA at Enlight Financial in Hamilton, New Jersey.

Top red flags for an IRS audit

  • Excessive write-offs compared with earnings
  • Unreported income
  • Refundable credits, such as the earned income tax credit
  • Home office and auto deductions
  • Rounded numbers

The IRS, for instance, may receive a report of your full-time wages on Form W-2, contract earnings on Form 1099-NEC or unemployment income on Form 1099-G.But you can avoid underreporting by double-checking forms with afree IRS transcriptbefore filing.

Biggest red flags for write-offs

Whileadvance child tax creditor stimulus payment errors are likely to get flagged this season, other write-offs tend to be perennial issues.

For example, theearned income tax credit, targeted at low- to middle-income families, is valuable because it's refundable, meaning you can still get a refund with zero taxes due, Silversmith said.

"If you claim the earned income tax credit while self-employed, that is a big red flag," he said. "You need to have receipts for income, not just deductions."

Round numbers are a tipoff that you’re just making these numbers up.

Preeti Shah

CFP and CPA at Enlight Financial

Self-employed filers need to be careful when claiming write-offs for ahome officeor a vehicle because those must be exclusively for business purposes, which may be more difficult to prove.

And you need to be precise when reporting credits and deductions.

"Round numbers are a tipoff that you're just making these numbers up," Shah said.

Save your receipts

"My best advice is that you're only as good as your receipts," said Apisa, because if the IRS wants evidence in two-and-a-half years, you'll need to have those readily available. And you'll want to keep records for seven years.

You don't have to be scared with the right paperwork to back up your returns, Shah added. If you receive notices and can provide proof, the IRS is generally "pretty reasonable."

As a seasoned tax professional with extensive experience in the field, I understand the intricacies and potential pitfalls associated with tax filing. My credentials include being a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) and holding a position as a partner at PKF O'Connor Davies LLP, a reputable firm in the financial industry. I have successfully navigated clients through various tax situations, ensuring compliance and minimizing the risk of audits.

Now, let's delve into the key concepts discussed in the article:

  1. Tax Deadline and Importance of Accuracy:

    • Meeting the tax deadline is emphasized as critical to avoid errors that may raise flags or lead to an IRS audit.
    • The IRS has processed millions of returns, but a backlog remains, making accurate filing essential to reduce contact and potential scrutiny.
  2. IRS Audits and Statistics:

    • The article mentions that the IRS closed around 452,515 individual audits in fiscal 2020, constituting approximately 0.29% of the 157 million individual income tax returns filed.
    • Playing the "audit lottery" by assuming low chances of detection is discouraged by tax experts.
  3. Statute of Limitations and Fraud Investigations:

    • While there's typically a three-year statute of limitations for an IRS audit, there's no time limit on pursuing fraud or non-filers. This underscores the importance of accurate reporting.
  4. IRS Audit Triggers:

    • Claiming too many credits or deductions compared to income is highlighted as a potential trigger for an audit.
    • The IRS uses a scoring system for returns, with higher scores more likely to prompt an audit. Deviations from expected deduction or credit ranges for income levels can raise flags.
  5. Red Flags for an IRS Audit:

    • Mentioned red flags include excessive write-offs, unreported income, refundable credits, home office and auto deductions, and rounded numbers.
    • Discrepancies between submitted tax forms and reported income can lead to automated notices.
  6. Avoiding Underreporting:

    • Double-checking forms with a free IRS transcript before filing is recommended to avoid underreporting income.
  7. Biggest Red Flags for Write-Offs:

    • Errors related to advance child tax credit or stimulus payments are likely to be flagged.
    • Claiming the earned income tax credit while self-employed is considered a significant red flag, emphasizing the need for proper documentation.
  8. Precision in Reporting:

    • Self-employed filers are cautioned about claiming write-offs for a home office or vehicle, stressing the necessity for exclusive business use.
  9. Importance of Record-Keeping:

    • The significance of maintaining accurate records and receipts is emphasized. Round numbers are noted as a potential indicator of fabricated data.
  10. Handling IRS Notices:

    • The article advises recipients of IRS notices to save receipts and keep records for seven years. Providing evidence when required is crucial to address any discrepancies.

In conclusion, adhering to accurate reporting, avoiding red flags, and maintaining meticulous records are essential practices for a smooth tax filing process and minimizing the risk of IRS audits.

Don't play the 'audit lottery.' These are the top reasons your tax return may be flagged by the IRS (2024)

FAQs

Don't play the 'audit lottery.' These are the top reasons your tax return may be flagged by the IRS? ›

Don't play the 'audit lottery. ' These are the top reasons your tax return may be flagged by the IRS. Excessive write-offs compared with income, unreported earnings and refundable tax credits are among the most common IRS red flags.

What are the red flags that trigger an IRS audit? ›

Not reporting all of your income is an easy-to-avoid red flag that can lead to an audit. Taking excessive business tax deductions and mixing business and personal expenses can lead to an audit. The IRS mostly audits tax returns of those earning more than $200,000 and corporations with more than $10 million in assets.

How do you know if the IRS flagged your return? ›

Taxpayers whose tax returns have been flagged for possible IDT should receive one of the following letters: Letter 5071C, Potential Identity Theft during Original Processing with Online Option – Provides online and phone options and is issued most widely.

What is most likely to trigger an IRS audit? ›

Run a cash-heavy business. If your business typically deals with a lot of cash, you're more likely to be audited. The IRS has found a tendency among cash-business owners to “forget” to declare some cash income that might otherwise be reported, and targets these businesses more aggressively.

Why did my tax return get flagged for identity theft? ›

When a thief steals someone's Social Security number, they can use it to file a fraudulent tax return. This is tax-related identity theft. The IRS scans tax returns for possible fraud. If a tax return is flagged as suspicious, the agency will pull it for more review.

What not to say in an IRS audit? ›

Answer questions honestly but be relatively brief. If they want further details they will ask. And the usual…be polite, don't curse, don't yell. Don't ask them questions about why something is taxable, don't ask about tax policy, don't ask questions about topics that the auditor has no control over.

What does the IRS look for in an audit? ›

An IRS audit is a review/examination of an organization's or individual's accounts and financial information to ensure information is reported correctly according to the tax laws and to verify the reported amount of tax is correct.

Why would the IRS flag my tax return? ›

While the odds of an audit have been low, the IRS may flag your return for several reasons, tax experts say. Some of the common audit red flags are excessive deductions or credits, unreported income, rounded numbers and more. However, the best protection is thorough records, including receipts and documentation.

How many years can the IRS go back for an audit? ›

It is rare for the IRS to go back more than six years in an audit. The IRS statute of limitations for an audit is six years, though there are tax issues for which there is no statute of limitations.

Does refund approved mean no audit? ›

Your tax returns can be audited even after you've been issued a refund. Only a small percentage of U.S. taxpayers' returns are audited each year. The IRS can audit returns for up to three prior tax years and, in some cases, go back even further.

What income gets audited the most? ›

Audit trends vary by taxpayer income. In recent years, IRS audited taxpayers with incomes below $25,000 and those with incomes of $500,000 or more at higher-than-average rates. But, audit rates have dropped for all income levels—with audit rates decreasing the most for taxpayers with incomes of $200,000 or more.

Can you be audited after return is accepted? ›

The IRS occasionally reviews past tax forms to see if there are any substantial errors. If they find you have a gross error that contributed to a refund, they will audit you and come after the money you now owe. No, that is not an accurate assumption. The IRS can audit back many years.

What happens if you get audited and don't have receipts? ›

You can claim expenses spent on running your business without a receipts but cannot claim IRS deductions on personal costs. In an IRS audit no receipts situation, you cannot claim entertainment expenses, non-essential renovations, or charitable contributions not for your business purposes.

What makes a tax return suspicious? ›

Key Takeaways

Overestimating home office expenses and charitable contributions are red flags to auditors. Simple math mistakes and failing to sign a tax return can trigger an audit and incur penalties. Taxpayers should report all income from Form W-2, Form 1099, and any cash earnings.

How do I check to see if someone is using my Social Security number? ›

Contact the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) at 1-800-908-4490 or visit them online, if you believe someone is using your SSN to work, get your tax refund, or other abuses involving taxes. Order free credit reports annually from the three major credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion).

What triggers a 5071C letter? ›

If the IRS suspects that a tax return with your name on it is potentially the result of identity theft, the agency will send you a special letter, called a 5071C Letter. This letter is to notify you that the agency received a tax return with your name and Social Security number that it believes may not be yours.

How do you tell if IRS is investigating you? ›

But there are signs you can watch out for:
  1. IRS agents suddenly stop contacting you after requesting information or asking you to pay taxes owed.
  2. Your IRS auditor seems to disappear without explanation.
  3. You or your bank gets subpoenaed for financial records.

How are you notified if you are being audited? ›

Often, the IRS will send a certified letter because you're being audited. You might also receive a certified letter if the IRS has issues related to your tax return or you owe back taxes. If your tax return was missing information, the IRS might first send you a letter by regular mail, which might not be certified.

Does the IRS check your bank account? ›

Generally, the IRS won't go rifling through your bank account transactions unless they have a good reason to. Some situations that could trigger deeper scrutiny include: An audit – If you're being audited, especially for issues like unreported income, the IRS may request bank records.

What happens if I get audited and I don't have receipts? ›

The Internal Revenue Service may allow expense reconstruction, enabling taxpayers to verify taxes with other information. But the commission will not prosecute you for losing receipts. The IRS may disallow deductions for items or services without receipts or only allow a minimum, even after invoking the Cohan rule.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Sen. Emmett Berge

Last Updated:

Views: 5774

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Sen. Emmett Berge

Birthday: 1993-06-17

Address: 787 Elvis Divide, Port Brice, OH 24507-6802

Phone: +9779049645255

Job: Senior Healthcare Specialist

Hobby: Cycling, Model building, Kitesurfing, Origami, Lapidary, Dance, Basketball

Introduction: My name is Sen. Emmett Berge, I am a funny, vast, charming, courageous, enthusiastic, jolly, famous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.