Carriage of goods - Liability, Limitations, and Misdelivery (2024)

Everywhere, carriers incur a measure of liability for the safety of the goods. In common-law countries carriers are liable for any damage or for the loss of the goods that are in their possession as carriers, unless they prove that the damage or loss is attributable to certain excepted causes. The excepted causes at common law include acts of God, acts of enemies of the crown, fault of the shipper, inherent vices of the goods, and fraud of the shipper. In maritime carriage perils of the sea and particularly jettison are added to the list of excepted causes. All these terms have technical meanings. An act of God is an operation of natural forces so unexpected that no human foresight or skill may be reasonably expected to anticipate it. Acts of enemies of the crown are acts of enemy soldiers in time of war or acts of rebels against the crown in civil war; violent acts of strikers or rioters are not an excepted cause. Fault of the shipper as an excepted cause is any negligent act or omission that has caused damage or loss—for example, faulty packing. Inherent vice is some default or defect latent in the thing itself, which, by its development, tends to the injury or destruction of the thing carried. Fraud of the shipper is an untrue statement as to the nature or value of the goods. And jettison in maritime transport is an intentional sacrifice of goods to preserve the safety of the ship and cargo.

When goods are damaged or lost as a result of an excepted cause, the carrier is still liable if he has contributed to the loss by his negligence or intentional misconduct. In this case, however, the burden of proof of the carrier’s fault rests on the plaintiff.

In civil-law countries the carrier under a contract of carriage is ordinarily bound as a warrantor for any damage to or loss of the goods carried, unless he proves that the damage or loss has resulted from irresistible force (force majeure), the inherent vice of the goods, or from the fault of the shipper or of the consignee. This contractual liability of the carrier under the general law is frequently modified by special legislation or by international conventions. In addition to his contractual liability, the carrier may, of course, incur liabilities that arise without contract. The carrier’s contractual liability is often termed an “obligation of result,” because the carrier, or a warrantor, is bound to make full restitution, unless he manages to exculpate himself in part or in whole.

Limitations of liability

In the absence of contrary legislation or decisions, carriers in common-law jurisdictions have been traditionally free to exclude or limit their liabilities by contract. In civil-law jurisdictions, as a rule, contractual clauses tending to limit liability for negligence or for willful misconduct have been considered null and void. Today, in most countries, municipal legislation and international conventions ordinarily limit the liability of certain carriers to a specified amount per weight, package, or unit of the goods carried. In this way, the liability of certain carriers has largely become standardized, at least in international carriage of goods.

Parties are free to stipulate that the carrier shall be liable in excess of any statutory limitation, but clauses that are designed to reduce the liability of the carrier below statutory limits are ordinarily null and void. Statutory limitations cover both direct and indirect losses incurred by shippers or consignees. In most legal systems, the benefit of statutory limitation of liability is unavailable if the goods have been delivered to the wrong individual or if the carrier is guilty of either intentional misconduct or gross negligence.

The liability of a maritime carrier for loss or damage to goods carried under a bill of lading is limited in most countries to a specified amount per package or unit by application of the provisions of the Brussels Convention of 1924 or by municipal legislation containing rules similar to those of the convention. The liability of air carriers for loss or damage to goods carried in international trade is almost everywhere controlled by the provisions of the Warsaw Convention of 1929, as amended by the Hague Protocol of 1955. Air carriage in domestic trade is subject either to the rules of the international convention or to municipal legislation patterned after the model of the convention. In most countries the liability of railroad carriers is limited by legislation or administrative regulations that regularly become part of the contract of carriage. International carriage of goods by railroad is largely subject to the various Berne Conventions, the first of which was adopted in 1890. Most European nations have adhered to these conventions.

Components of the carriage of goods

The law of carriage of goods covers a variety of matters.

Delay and misdelivery

In all legal systems, carriers incur liability for delay in delivering the goods to the consignee. Statutes, international conventions, administrative regulations, or even contractual agreements may fix the period of transportation with reference to the applicable means of carriage and determine the consequences of the delay. Under the law of contracts, failure of the carrier to deliver the goods within the prescribed period of time will be treated as a breach of contract.

In common-law jurisdictions, if the delay is caused by a deviation, the carrier is ordinarily answerable for damages. A deviation takes place when the carrier leaves the route that he has expressly or impliedly agreed to follow or when he goes past his destination. In civil-law jurisdictions, carriers are not bound to follow any particular route in the absence of special legislation or contractual agreement. Thus, a deviation from the normal route does not itself constitute a fault of the carrier; if the deviation causes a delay, the carrier will be liable only if he is at fault.

Like delay, misdelivery engages the responsibility of the carrier. Misdelivery is the delivery of the goods by the carrier to the wrong person or to the wrong place.

Carriage of goods - Liability, Limitations, and Misdelivery (2024)

FAQs

What is the carrier's liability for misdelivery? ›

If the carrier, without authority, delivers the goods to another carrier, he is liable to the shipper for any misdelivery by the second carrier and for any loss or damage suffered by the owner of the goods during the time in which the goods were in the possession of the second carrier.

What is limitation of liability in carriage of goods? ›

In case of loss or damage to the cargo, the carrier's limitation of liability allows that every party with an economic interest in the transport operation retains a portion of the risk of such loss or damage. These economically interested parties are the shipper (or consignee), the carrier and the cargo insurer.

What is the package limitation for Cogsa? ›

CARRIAGE OF GOODS BY SEA ACT (COGSA)

One of the most well-known and controversial provisions of COGSA is its $500 per-package limitation. Under COGSA §4(5), if a package is lost or its contents destroyed, the carrier may be entitled to limit their liability to $500.

What is the 500 package limitation for Cogsa? ›

Section 1304(5) of COGSA provides that a carrier may limit its liability to USD 500 per package, or for goods not shipped packaged, per customary freight unit, unless the nature and value of the goods have been declared by the shipper before shipment and inserted in the bill of lading.

What is misdelivery in shipping? ›

Carriers face misdelivery claims when they deliver cargo without production of original bills of lading, but then someone else claiming to be the 'lawful holder' of the bills complains the cargo should have been delivered to them instead.

What is a misdelivery? ›

: to deliver (something) to the wrong person or address. misdeliver a letter/package. misdelivery.

What is an example of limitation of liability? ›

For example, if the software doesn't work and the company suffers damages as a result, the limitation of liability will restrict the company's ability to recoup its loss.

What are common exceptions to limitation of liability? ›

Examples of exclusions from limitations of liability include losses resulting from a breach of confidentiality, refusal to provide services, death, bodily injury, damage to tangible property, violation of applicable law, gross negligence or willful misconduct.

What are the two components of a limitation of liability? ›

A limitation of liability provision typically contains two parts: a waiver of damages and a liability cap. The waiver of damages clause typically limits a party's exposure only to direct damages (i.e., damages suffered by a party that naturally result from the breach of the other party).

What is the statute of limitations to bring a lawsuit under cogsa for cargo loss or damage? ›

Minimum two year statute of limitations; 3. Damages: made carriers liable for actual damages; 4. Liability limitations: carriers allowed to limit liability to released values. In the 1980s, there was a series of legislation which signaled the deregulation of the transportation industry.

What are the limitations of the carrier's liability under the Hague-Visby Rules? ›

Under article 4.5(e) of the Hague-Visby Rules, the carrier is not entitled to limit its liability if it is proved that the damage resulted from an act or omission of the carrier done with intent to cause damage or recklessly and with knowledge that a damage would probably result.

What is the maximum carrier liability under the Hague-Visby Rules? ›

Article IV Rules 5 of the Hague-Visby Rules limits a carrier's liability for loss or damage to goods to 666.67 SDR per package(s) or unit(s) or 2 SDR per kilogram of gross weight, whichever is higher.

What is the maximum compensation the shipper can receive based on weight Limitation if the goods were carried by sea? ›

The Hague- Visby Rules are sometimes referred to as a convention of lesser liability of the carrier, as it is a maximum of 2 SDRs for one kilogram of gross cargo weight (or 666.67 SDR per unit).

What is considered as the total carrying capacity in shipping? ›

Deadweight Tonnage (DWT) - The total carrying capacity of a ship expressed in long tons (2,240 lbs.) on a specified draft. The deadweight tonnage includes the total weight of cargoes, fuel, water in tanks, stores, baggage, passengers, crew, and their effects but exclude the water in the boilers.

What is a Cogsa package? ›

When goods are packaged, the packages are put into a container or shipped on pallets, and the bill of lading discloses the number of packages within the container or on the pallet, the COGSA package is not the container or the pallet. The COGSA packages are each package within the container or on the pallet.

Is keeping a misdelivered package theft? ›

Under this view, whether an unintended recipient receives misdelivered or misaddressed mail, it is unlawful to remove any such item from the mail and possess it with the intent of preventing the item from reaching its intended recipient. Such mail is considered stolen and is protected by § 1708.

How do you avoid shipping mistakes? ›

How to Prevent Shipping Errors
  1. Partner with Reliable Shipping Services. ...
  2. Implement an Automated Warehouse System. ...
  3. Leverage an End-to-End Shipment Tracking Service. ...
  4. Conduct Regular Product and Inventory Location Checks. ...
  5. Double-Check Order Information. ...
  6. Offer Focused Shipping Options. ...
  7. Be Smart About Your Packaging.

What happens if you get the wrong package? ›

When you receive a mistaken delivery, call customer service for the delivery company and explain the situation. Give them the tracking number on the package, as well as the name and address on the package if it's different from yours. The company will come and pick up the product within a reasonable time frame.

How do you handle misdirected mail? ›

If the mailpiece is delivered to the wrong location:
  1. Don't erase or mark over the information, or write any type of endorsem*nt on the mailpiece.
  2. Place the item back in the mailbox or hand the item back to your mailperson.

What happens if I shipped to wrong address? ›

The package will either be redirected to your new recipient, held at a local Post Office for pick up, or returned to you to be re-sent with the correct information.

What happens if you deliver a package to the wrong address? ›

Your shipment will be redirected to the original sender or held at the local Post Office for pickup.

What are 5 examples of liabilities? ›

Examples of liabilities are -
  • Bank debt.
  • Mortgage debt.
  • Money owed to suppliers (accounts payable)
  • Wages owed.
  • Taxes owed.

How do you explain limitations of liability? ›

A limitation of liability clause in a contract limits the amount of money or damages that one party can recover from another party for breaches or performance failures. In other words, the clause can put a cap on the number of damages the organization will have to pay under certain circ*mstances.

What does limitation to liability mean? ›

Limitation of liability means a contractual provision to reduce or exclude the types and amounts of liabilities one party may recover from another party relating to default or non-performance in connection with a contract.

Are limitations of liability enforceable? ›

The short of it is that limitations of liability are generally upheld and enforceable by the courts.

What Cannot be excluded from liability? ›

You can't exclude liability for death or personal injury caused by your negligence. 3. You can only exclude liability for other losses caused by your negligence, if reasonable.

Does limitation of liability apply to negligence? ›

It is common for parties to unambiguously state that an overall limitation of liability applies in the case of negligence. The use of general words, such as “any loss” or “loss howsoever caused” may not be sufficient to encompass liability for negligence.

What is the unenforceable limitation of liability clause? ›

Limitation of liability clauses in contracts are provisions that limit how much exposure a business faces if a lawsuit is ever filed against it. If enforceable, the limitation of liability clause can limit the amount of potential damages when a business is exposed.

What are basic limits of liability? ›

Limit of liability refers to the max amount of money your insurer is on the hook for if something bad happens to you, your stuff, or your property.

What are examples of direct damages? ›

Direct damages are those that accident victims incur immediately as the result of the collision. They might include ambulance transport, hospital bills, property loss, and rehabilitation costs.

Who shall be liable for damages from the losses or damage of the cargoes in case of a marine accident? ›

The Athens Convention relating to the Carriage of Passengers and their Luggage by Sea declares the carrier liable for damage or loss suffered by passengers if the incident is due to the fault or the neglect of the carrier. The limit of liability was set at 46,666 Special drawing Right (SDR) per carriage.

What damages can you get for unseaworthiness? ›

Types of damages available on an unseaworthiness claim include loss of income, medical expenses, pain and suffering, compensation for disability, and other damages available under maritime law.

What are the time limits for cargo claims? ›

Acknowledgment of Cargo Claims (49 CFR § 370.5).

Upon receipt of a properly filed cargo claim, the motor carrier (or their agent, such as an insurance adjuster) must acknowledge receipt of the claim in writing to the claimant within 30 days.

What are limitation of liability and indemnification obligations? ›

Indemnification usually transfers risk between the parties to the contract. Limitation of liability prevents or limits the transfer of risk between the parties. With those basic concepts in mind, think about the risks that arise out or relate to the contract.

What are Hague Rules and Cogsa? ›

The Hague/COGSA Act was developed to protect vessel owners against legal liability to shippers for circ*mstances out of their control. It was conceived during the post World War I era when vessel owners had little jurisdiction over their ships once they left port.

What is the carrier liability under the Hague Rules? ›

The Hague/Visby scheme of liability is built on specific obligations by which the carrier is bound, i.e. the obligation to issue a bill of lading, obligation to exercise due diligence, to provide a seaworthy ship and the obligation of care of cargo.

In what circ*mstances would the Hague-Visby Rules make the carrier liable for loss or damage to goods? ›

Neither the carrier nor the ship shall be liable for loss or damage arising or resulting from unseaworthiness unless caused by want of due diligence on the part of the carrier to make the ship seaworthy, and to secure that the ship is properly manned, equipped and supplied, and to make the holds, refrigerating and cool ...

What is carrier maximum liability? ›

Carrier limits of liability determines the maximum amount a carrier can be held liable for in the event of damage, loss or delays to your freight shipping.

What is the strict liability of common carriers? ›

The Interstate Commerce Act, Section 20 (ll), indicates that a common carrier shall be absolutely liable without proof of negligence for all loss, damage, or injury to goods transported by it unless the carrier can affirmatively show that the damage was occasioned by one of the exceptions to common law liability ...

What is limitation of liability in cargo claims? ›

The Carrier limit of liability determines the maximum amount of money that carriers can be held liable for in the event of damage, loss, or delay of cargo. However, limits of liability vary between carriers and situations.

What is the evidence of the contract of carriage? ›

The bill of lading is evidence of the contract of carriage, it is not the contract of carriage itself. That contract between the carrier and the shipper is created when the goods are loaded on board the ship and will therefore already exist before the bill of lading is issued.

What is the maximum weight a 40ft container can carry? ›

40' Container Max Load: 59,200 lbs.

Due to similarities in cargo capacity between a 20ft container and 40ft container, it is important to know which size to choose to meet your requirements. Below is some helpful information, to assist you in choosing the right container size.

What is the load capacity of a 40ft container? ›

40ft container sizes and capacity

The payload of a 40ft container is 27,600 kgs and the cubic capacity is 67.7 cubic meters. 40ft container size is also available in specialized containers like reefers, open-tops, hard-tops, etc. Read on to get the measurements of different types of 40ft containers.

What is maximum carrying capacity? ›

Carrying capacity is the maximum number of a species an environment can support indefinitely. Every species has a carrying capacity, even humans. However, it is very difficult for ecologists to calculate human carrying capacity.

What is the $500 package limitation for Cogsa? ›

Per-Package Limitation

Usually, pursuant to COGSA, when cargo is damaged or lost in situations that are not within the 17 enumerated defenses, the shipper is entitled to recover damages. COGSA limits carrier liability to 500 dollars per package in these instances.

What is the difference between Hague Visby and Cogsa? ›

COGSA is an enactment of the Hague-Visby Rules, an international set of regulations related to cargo, vessel operators, and shippers. These rules were initially drafted in Brussels in 1924 and amended in 1968 and 1979.

What is the legal contract between the shipper and carrier? ›

A bill of lading is a legal document between a shipper and a transport company (carrier) that spells out the type, quantity, and destination of the goods being transported. An invoice tracks the sale of goods between a buyer and a seller.

What is the liability coverage for the carriers? ›

Carrier liability typically only covers damage or loss that occurred due to the carrier's negligence. In many cases, in order to settle a claim, the shipper must prove that the damage was the carrier's fault.

What are the liabilities of the carrier of goods? ›

(1) The liability of the common carrier for loss of, or damage to any consignment, shall be limited to such amount as may be prescribed having regard to the value, freight and nature of goods, documents or articles of the consignment, unless the consignor or any person duly authorised in that behalf have expressly ...

What is a common carrier liable for? ›

Liability. Under the laws, a common carrier is generally liable for all losses which may occur to property entrusted to their charge during the course of business.

What is carrier legal liability policy? ›

Carrier legal liability insurance policy is designed to cover an insured and indemnify against his/her legal liability for physical and actual damage to or loss of merchandise or goods directly caused by an accident and or fire to the vehicle registered under the number stated in the policy at the same time as such ...

What is the difference between carrier liability and insurance? ›

Unlike freight insurance where you pay a fee to cover you in the event of a damaged shipment, carrier liability limits show the maximum amount a carrier is liable to pay out when damage occurs. Liability limits can cover the full value of the loss but they could also only cover a percentage of the value lost".

Are common carriers liable for cargo? ›

Common carriers offer their services to the general public and are liable for the cargo under terms of the bill of lading. Contract carriers haul for specific shippers based on terms of a negotiated contract and are liable to the shipper subject to the terms of that contract.

What are 3 examples of liabilities? ›

Examples of liabilities are -
  • Bank debt.
  • Mortgage debt.
  • Money owed to suppliers (accounts payable)
  • Wages owed.
  • Taxes owed.

What are 3 examples of known liabilities? ›

Some common examples of current liabilities include:
  • Accounts payable, i.e. payments you owe your suppliers.
  • Principal and interest on a bank loan that is due within the next year.
  • Salaries and wages payable in the next year.
  • Notes payable that are due within one year.
  • Income taxes payable.
  • Mortgages payable.
  • Payroll taxes.
Jan 6, 2020

What are the 4 types of carriers? ›

The four main types of carriers for shipping in logistics are trucking, railroads, ocean and air cargo.

What are the 3 types of carriers? ›

Types of carrier of goods
  • common carriers.
  • private carriers.
  • other types of carriers with special rights and duties.
Nov 10, 2022

In what instances that the carrier or ship is not liable? ›

This means that the carrier is not liable for damage to the cargo resulting from the unseaworthy condition if the defective condition rendering the vessel unseaworthy is not reasonably discoverable, or it arose after the vessel's voyage commenced.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duncan Muller

Last Updated:

Views: 5753

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duncan Muller

Birthday: 1997-01-13

Address: Apt. 505 914 Phillip Crossroad, O'Konborough, NV 62411

Phone: +8555305800947

Job: Construction Agent

Hobby: Shopping, Table tennis, Snowboarding, Rafting, Motor sports, Homebrewing, Taxidermy

Introduction: My name is Duncan Muller, I am a enchanting, good, gentle, modern, tasty, nice, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.