8 Truths From a Mystery Shopper You Must Read Before You Get Started (2024)

3190584489_b581ef7b51_z.jpg

Photo credit:

lu_lu / Flickr

I have a few friends who have started mystery shopping for extra cash. All in all, it's a respectable gig for someone with some time, ambition, and a desire to do something different. Having mystery shopped for dozens of companies over the past six years, however, I have some advice to share. These eight tips are vital to making money in this somewhat misunderstood profession. (See also: Fine Dining on a Take-Out Budget)

1. Mystery shopping can be tough to get into.

If you're OK with starting out doing $8 gigs for ordering a fast food meal, then chances are great that you can begin right away. The higher paying shops, however, are usually reserved for those with experience. If you want to earn a reputation for being a dependable shopper, I suggest visiting the MSPA's website and getting at least a silver status certification. Yes, it costs money. (Think of it as a "move to the head of the line" pass for most mystery shopping jobs.) Many reputable companies will only schedule certified shoppers for their jobs.

2. You can't earn money if you don't spend it.

Guess what? Mystery shopping requires you to shop (in most cases). Since they don't mail you cash up front, it is your responsibility to be able to cover your purchases for the shop. It also takes between 30 and 90 days to get reimbursed. If you can't spare this money, this may not be the job for you.

3. A successful shop requires an eye for detail.

I loved doing the fine dining shops. The problem was, I had a difficult time remembering all the details I needed to complete the shop. I had to covertly keep tabs on the names of every person I came in contact with, what they were wearing, what they said, what my food tasted like, etc. Needless to say it was work! If you are looking for mystery shopping to be your free meal ticket, understand that there will not be much time for relaxing. While it is true that some shops require little work, others require much, much more.

4. Payment depends on your performance.

Unlike a typical 9-5 job, you are not guaranteed payment unless your shop has been performed satisfactorily. If you forget the names of your wait staff, don't leave the right amount of tip, or accidentally reveal your shopper status, you are putting your reimbursem*nt in danger. I have never had a shopping company not pay me, but I have also been very diligent about doing everything perfectly. If you don't take it seriously, you may not be paid — and you'll be out whatever cash you put into your shopping experience.

5. There are other costs involved.

In addition to the cost of your shopping (which is usually reimbursed partially or in full), there are other costs. Gas to drive to the shop, the cost (if any) to put an item on your credit card until reimbursem*nt, or the cost of a tip (which is often not covered) are just a few expenses that may come up during a typical shop. Obviously, the best strategy is to shop close, only take shops that reimburse in full (and with an extra shopper's fee, if possible), and turn in your reports on time.

6. You are responsible for your own taxes.

As a mystery shopper, you are considered an independent contractor. While it is unlikely that you will earn over $600 a year for any one company, you will still be responsible for reporting that income on your tax returns. You can count it as self-employment, deducting expenses as needed, so keep track of the cost of your new mystery shopping job.

7. Some mystery shopping isn't shopping or a mystery.

Many shopping companies have begun scheduling work for companies that aren't even related to mystery shopping. Audits, merchandising, and other tasks (including headstone cleaning) often come up on the mystery shopping job boards from time to time. If you don't have an interest in these types of jobs, don't feel obliged to take them. They can be a good source of income for you, however.

8. A reputable mystery shopping company will never ask you for any kind of fee.

I'll say this again: You should not have to ever pay for the "privilege" to shop. You are performing a service, and should get paid. Any fee that is guaranteed to get you a list of jobs is bogus. For a genuine listing of most every single shop service on the planet, see Volition.com or check out JobSlinger.com. It costs nothing. (And be sure to read up on the latest mystery shopping scams — I have never, ever, ever been asked to cash checks in my six years of shopping. Ever.)

After some time, I gave up on mystery shopping. The $8-10 an hour wasn't worth the work (especially as my family grew). For some, this could still be a really good deal. Just be aware of the facts, and decide what's right for you. I still enjoy a nice hotel shop from time to time. (Hubby and I enjoy getting away for a night at an eventual cost of free.)

Like this article? Pin it!

8 Truths From a Mystery Shopper You Must Read Before You Get Started (2024)

FAQs

What questions do mystery shoppers ask? ›

  • What was your overall impression? Photo Comment. ...
  • What was done well or impressed you? Photo Comment. ...
  • What could be improved? Photo Comment. ...
  • Any other comments? ...
  • Is parking available near the building? ...
  • Could you easily locate the place? ...
  • Were there visible signs directing to the entrance? ...
  • Was the building easy to find?

What are the three good qualities a mystery shopper must have? ›

To become a Mystery Shopper, you will need:
  • excellent communication skills.
  • an eye for fashion and styling if that is an area you wish to work in.
  • a positive outlook.
  • an enthusiastic, confident and friendly manner.
  • the stamina to spend a long time standing and walking around.
  • a smart appearance.
  • excellent written skills.

How to be a successful mystery shopper? ›

Skills and characteristics of good mystery shoppers
  1. Follow directions. The first thing a mystery shopper has to be good at is following directions. ...
  2. Honesty. Honesty is paramount for mystery shoppers. ...
  3. Friendliness. Mystery shoppers should be friendly individuals. ...
  4. Writing skills. ...
  5. Eye for detail. ...
  6. Good memory.

Do mystery shoppers really get paid? ›

As of Apr 29, 2024, the average weekly pay for a Mystery Shopper in the United States is $714 a week. While ZipRecruiter is seeing weekly wages as high as $1,135 and as low as $375, the majority of Mystery Shopper wages currently range between $644 (25th percentile) to $730 (75th percentile) across the United States.

What is a disadvantage of a mystery shopper? ›

Disadvantages of Mystery Shopping - Insufficient Data, Biased Data, Workforce Anxiety. Mystery shopping has become a popular method for companies to gather data and assess the quality of their services. However, despite its benefits, this method has its fair share of disadvantages.

How do I become a high end mystery shopper? ›

Here's how a mystery shop usually works: You join a mystery shopping company, such as Bestmark, and fill out a mystery shopper application. Apply for and find mystery shopper jobs through the platform. This is an easy way to become a mystery shopper online.

How can I improve my mystery shopper results? ›

4 Tips to Maximize Mystery Shopping Results Across Your...
  1. Analyze a Specific Aspect of the Customer Experience. ...
  2. Keep the Assignments Simple. ...
  3. Provide Adequate Value to The Shopper. ...
  4. Choose the Right Mystery Shopping Vendor.

What are the best practices in mystery shopping? ›

10 Best Practices to Follow and Know More With Mystery Shopping
  • Table of Contents.
  • Predefine Objectives. ...
  • Include A Mix of Subjective & Objective Questions. ...
  • Communicate With Brand's Staff. ...
  • Use It To Encourage Employees. ...
  • Never Aim For High Scores. ...
  • Plan An Employee Rewards Program. ...
  • Deploy Consistent Programs.
Mar 14, 2024

What is a good mystery shopper score? ›

Looking at these numbers, we think it is safe to say that any score below 80% should be considered sub-par, anything in the 80s should be considered average or good, and anything in the 90s should be considered excellent (relatively speaking).

How much does a mystery shopper get paid in the US? ›

Mystery shoppers typically receive minimum wage or better. Job listings website Indeed puts the average hourly pay of a mystery shopper in the U.S. at $15.41 an hour, within a probabl range of $7.25 to $55.38.

Is it fun to be a mystery shopper? ›

Exciting Experiences

Becoming a Mystery Shopper can turn these everyday, normally trivial, experiences into exciting and exhilarating parts of your day. Mystery shopping is a great way to experience new places, stores, and foods, all while getting paid!

Do you pay taxes as a mystery shopper? ›

Do Mystery Shoppers Pay Taxes? The IRS requires you to pay taxes on mystery shopping income if you earn at least $400 annually from it.

What is the best mystery shopper company to work for? ›

Below are the best mystery shopping companies.
  • BestMark. BestMark is one of the biggest mystery shopping companies with a great reputation, and they have many different kinds of mystery shopping jobs available. ...
  • Ath Power Consulting. ...
  • IntelliShop. ...
  • Market Force Information. ...
  • iSecretShop. ...
  • Secret Shopper. ...
  • Pinnacle. ...
  • A Closer Look.
Feb 19, 2024

Do mystery shoppers keep what they buy? ›

Can mystery shoppers keep what they buy? Usually, a shopper receives reimbursem*nt for their purchases and can keep the product or service they purchased. Those reviewing restaurants may receive a free meal but also may not receive payment for their assignment.

What do mystery shoppers check? ›

Mystery shopping is a method of testing the quality of services. It can be used to test the quality of products, customer service, or employee performance.

What do mystery shoppers assess? ›

Mystery shoppers assess their shopping experience by evaluating areas such as customer service, store presentation, product quality, add-on selling techniques, cleanliness and promotional material, based on a survey and guidelines provided for each assignment.

What to do if someone asks if you're a mystery shopper? ›

Most shopping companies will tell you the same thing. If you are approached DO NOT reveal yourself. Simply thank them for their time or wish them a nice day, leave and contact your scheduler immediately.

Do mystery shoppers ask for receipts? ›

If you are required to make a purchase as part of your assignment, you will need to keep your receipt. You may need to send us your receipt or provide us with receipt details, as proof of your visit.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tuan Roob DDS

Last Updated:

Views: 5695

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (42 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tuan Roob DDS

Birthday: 1999-11-20

Address: Suite 592 642 Pfannerstill Island, South Keila, LA 74970-3076

Phone: +9617721773649

Job: Marketing Producer

Hobby: Skydiving, Flag Football, Knitting, Running, Lego building, Hunting, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Tuan Roob DDS, I am a friendly, good, energetic, faithful, fantastic, gentle, enchanting person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.